http://www.erollisimarr.com/forum/ar...hp/t-7142.html
This post from 2002 has a paladin complaining about this same crit chance, "I've used holyforge and due to complaints from other paladins I've logged every crit Ive had. ( not hard when you get 2 every usage ) The last 2 times I've critted 12 times a go."
Maybe it's just classic. I do remember raiding in Hate and watching a paladin absolutely blow up undead, but I think he may have had AAs that increased crit chance and that could be why I am thinking the proc rate is higher than normal...