I actually found an old forum post from Ravager with that info last night after I made that post, headed out there this morning. About 2 hours in he finally popped, but he only had the shitty +3 AGI eyepatch.
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] Not sure if I'm just really unlucky or you were really lucky, maybe a little of both? I'll have to give it another shot later.
Thanks for bringing it up Skarlorn and thanks to Ravager for the info. I've made a hobby out of collecting obscure clickies of Norrath (that I always forget to use when I actually need them) so this will be a nice score, although I'll probably mostly stick to Wort Pots since they are 10 dose and spammable.