Possible ways to PvP (all optional)

[jyaku]

Guild PvP: Rogean's plan ATM, guild leaders say "hey i don't like your guild, lets fight" and the e-peen waving begins.

Good v Evil PvP: pretty much guild PvP only with just 2 sides.

FFA: if you want to PvP you turn it on/off via the PoD in all the citys. anybody can attack anybody as long as both are flagged for PvP.

I just want to see people's thoughts on these ways, i don't want to hear about "resists broken this" or "spell casters pwn all" that. this is just to see what way most people would want.

[eqdruid76]

You forgot the "This is not a pvp server" option.

[jyaku]

none of these would turn it into a pure PVP server, it's all player choice

[cured]

You forgot the "This is not a pvp server" option.

you forgot the "optional" part of the title

[Noselacri]

Guild war is the only form of PvP I want to see here. The Book of Discord turn-in is already there and has always been, but nobody does this because it makes your character useless for PvE. EQ PvP invariably fosters the most degenerate and annoying community imaginable, but with guild wars, this would be sufficiently situational and small-scale to not affect the playerbase as a whole.