Log in

View Full Version : Being this geared isn’t classic.


Wakanda
08-06-2025, 01:09 PM
You will never convince me that even if you had a Time Machine and could travel back in time that you would be able to get BIS from Velious era before Shadows of Luclin dropped ;)

I remember thinking it was absolutely bonkers that my friends TWINK had two blood points and an FBSS, and three pieces of mrylokars in era.

Meanwhile we LARPing that full skyshrine twinks was always the norm. Lmao, I remember people struggling to get full thurg armor on their mains, and spending months raiding plane of growth for armor drops on my own main 😹

Drueric
08-06-2025, 01:28 PM
This is what classic looks like, 10 years later.

Drueric
08-06-2025, 01:30 PM
The server needs to be wiped and restarted to experience that again, a least for awhile.

zelld52
08-06-2025, 01:33 PM
People in raiding guilds be like

"I need Ring 10, Primal Fistwraps, AoW pants and wort pots to level my monk from 57-60"

and at the same time be like "oh you want me to pull, nahh i dont do that"

shovelquest
08-06-2025, 01:33 PM
Thats why it should be that if you die in game, you die IRL.

shovelquest
08-06-2025, 01:34 PM
"I need Ring 10, Primal Fistwraps, AoW pants and wort pots to level my monk from 57-60"

"oh you want me to pull, nahh i dont do that"

:D

kjs86z2
08-06-2025, 02:12 PM
People in raiding guilds be like

"I need Ring 10, Primal Fistwraps, AoW pants and wort pots to level my monk from 57-60"

and at the same time be like "oh you want me to pull, nahh i dont do that"

If you aren't full BiS at level 46 you aren't even playing p99.

shovelquest
08-06-2025, 02:28 PM
All I know is if I don't get sent back in time soon Im gonna be pretty pissed off I memorized all these mechanics.

Ekco
08-06-2025, 02:33 PM
>I remember thinking it was absolutely bonkers that my friends TWINK had two blood points and an FBSS,

twinking was a problem in classic, i remember people being ostracized and made fun of in 1999 on fennin ro for having gear outside their level range and called ebayers

that being said, spending dkp on your lvl 52 alt barbies vox/naggy toons is quite literally peak p99

shovelquest
08-06-2025, 02:52 PM
I was addicted from day 1 and I was friggen level 54 when velious launched.

zelld52
08-06-2025, 04:00 PM
>I remember thinking it was absolutely bonkers that my friends TWINK had two blood points and an FBSS,

twinking was a problem in classic, i remember people being ostracized and made fun of in 1999 on fennin ro for having gear outside their level range and called ebayers

that being said, spending dkp on your lvl 52 alt barbies vox/naggy toons is quite literally peak p99

My friend got called an ebayer in 2000 because he had FBSS, 2x Lamentation and full crafted on his level 38 warrior

Ekco
08-06-2025, 04:44 PM
My friend got called an ebayer in 2000 because he had FBSS, 2x Lamentation and full crafted on his level 38 warrior

yeah it was def a thing, and being super racist toward SEA timezone lol

Swish
08-06-2025, 05:56 PM
My Velious experience (especially Kael raids etc) was mostly during the start of Luclin back in the day. I remember going to one with the raid window and being the only shaman on it having to buff everyone.

Time ticked to the next expansion faster than I'd have liked.

Ekco
08-06-2025, 06:22 PM
Time ticked to the next expansion faster than I'd have liked.

yeah, entire server knew i was 12 also so it didn't help

shovelquest
08-06-2025, 07:40 PM
My friend got called an ebayer in 2000 because he had FBSS, 2x Lamentation and full crafted on his level 38 warrior

ebayer LOL

cd288
08-07-2025, 10:59 AM
RecondoJoe, of course not. People aren't BIS before Luclin dropped because there is no Luclin on this server.

WarpathEQ
08-07-2025, 01:39 PM
The only raid loot I recall ever seeing sold for twinking on my live server was the blade of carnage, otherwise the most expensive gear you could buy was a fungi tunic. Custom velious helms were an extremely rare sighting (probably saw less than 5 myself) and that was when I left well into luclin launch before pop

Bardp1999
08-07-2025, 03:48 PM
Whats not classic is Discord, guild bot armies, rooted dragons, 500-600 population, and absolutely 0 innovation on the classic spirit of the game.

Ekco
08-07-2025, 04:11 PM
And that's stuff you can't actually fix, only way to make a emu actually classic is to find 1200 people that have never played before, stick them on island somewhere and just give them access to like a binder with some random info from castersrealm/ allahakazam and tell em to figure it the fuck out

i'd rather watch that as a tv show than try to theory craft some way to make bitter vets not be shitty

shovelquest
08-07-2025, 04:17 PM
Whats not classic is Discord, guild bot armies, rooted dragons, 500-600 population, and absolutely 0 innovation on the classic spirit of the game.

don't forget that damn wiki

FGvb0UtVEjY

Jimjam
08-07-2025, 05:03 PM
And that's stuff you can't actually fix, only way to make a emu actually classic is to find 1200 people that have never played before, stick them on island somewhere and just give them access to like a binder with some random info from castersrealm/ allahakazam and tell em to figure it the fuck out

i'd rather watch that as a tv show than try to theory craft some way to make bitter vets not be shitty

When we all have alzheimers and dementia it will be true classic 2.

shovelquest
08-07-2025, 07:38 PM
When we all have alzheimers and dementia it will be true classic 2.

https://i.imgur.com/vXPhjYs.png

zelld52
08-08-2025, 08:27 AM
When we all have alzheimers and dementia it will be true classic 2.

Jimjam just cracked the code - we're getting a new Green when 51% of us have alzheimers

Rygar
08-10-2025, 12:56 AM
I was addicted from day 1 and I was friggen level 54 when velious launched.

Totally my story.

Everytime I am like "I'm just logging on and grinding exp to get 60"

Then in guild someone be like " anyone available to help me camp a quillmane?"

Immediately I am like, "hopping on a boat, be there in 45. Level 49 warrior"

Zadrian
08-10-2025, 11:02 AM
And that's stuff you can't actually fix, only way to make a emu actually classic is to find 1200 people that have never played before, stick them on island somewhere and just give them access to like a binder with some random info from castersrealm/ allahakazam and tell em to figure it the fuck out

i'd rather watch that as a tv show than try to theory craft some way to make bitter vets not be shitty

Bring back Everlore!

Ekco
08-10-2025, 11:53 AM
Bring back Everlore!

Fuckin' A

Zuranthium
08-10-2025, 03:23 PM
And that's stuff you can't actually fix, only way to make a emu actually classic is to find 1200 people that have never played before

Nah, what's needed is dynamic content. Constantly change where items drop and how NPC's spawn. It doesn't require constant work either, just need to have an algorithm that automatically shifts everything around. Now the game is a permanent adventure, an Everquest, where nobody knows exactly what will happen and it becomes necessary to hunt throughout every nook and cranny of every zone to see what might be there at any given time.

zelld52
08-11-2025, 10:32 AM
Once Teddie completes EveryQuest the game is over, FYI.

shovelquest
08-11-2025, 12:15 PM
We all get erased and the sim starts over.

zelld52
08-11-2025, 12:22 PM
We all get erased and the sim starts over.

https://imgur.com/gallery/matrix-architect-nhEdSZ0

Teddie is the one

zelld52
08-11-2025, 12:23 PM
tf i put a picture of the Matrix Architect so people would get the joke

also, just found this out but did you know that the letters of NEO from the matrix are a clever anagram for a word to describe his impact on the story:

NEO is a prefix for NEW. as in NEW p99

Ekco
08-11-2025, 12:36 PM
it's not a anagram you fucking retard, it's a greek word.

Ekco
08-11-2025, 12:45 PM
my bad, sry.

zelld52
08-11-2025, 01:07 PM
it's not a anagram you fucking retard, it's a greek word.

so greek words cant be anagrams? what kinda 300 BC persian inspired racism is this

Jimjam
08-12-2025, 12:10 AM
Neo is an anagram of One though. And eon I guess.

Xer0
08-19-2025, 02:36 AM
My friend got called an ebayer in 2000 because he had FBSS, 2x Lamentation and full crafted on his level 38 warrior

As I recall, the term ebayer got thrown around when people had made it too far into their character progression to be as bad at the game for the behavior exhibited. snackpacc for example, would have been alled an ebayer.

Xer0
08-19-2025, 02:41 AM
it's not a anagram you fucking retard, it's a greek word.

nagram
/ăn′ə-grăm″/
noun
A transposition of the letters of a word or sentence, to form a new word or sentence: thus, Galenus is an anagram of angelus.

Wakanda
08-31-2025, 04:51 AM
My friend got called an ebayer in 2000 because he had FBSS, 2x Lamentation and full crafted on his level 38 warrior

tbf that was pretty op :p now its under geared

Ennewi
08-31-2025, 08:48 AM
tf i put a picture of the Matrix Architect so people would get the joke

also, just found this out but did you know that the letters of NEO from the matrix are a clever anagram for a word to describe his impact on the story:

NEO is a prefix for NEW. as in NEW p99

Mr. Anderson was a bit more clever, with Anders from Andreas, meaning man(ly) or masculine. So while it seems like an ordinary average Joe surname, he's being referred to as the son of man.

Dolalin
09-05-2025, 12:20 PM
>
that being said, spending dkp on your lvl 52 alt barbies vox/naggy toons is quite literally peak p99

I got chewed out by my guild on Lanys for spending DKP gearing up my vox/naggy alt with ntov junk... but that was towards the end of SoL haha.

Ciderpress
09-11-2025, 09:11 PM
*notices age of thread, detects comedic opportunity to necro it*

*breaths deep, cracks knuckles*

more like analgram.

Reiwa
09-11-2025, 09:26 PM
*notices age of thread, detects comedic opportunity to necro it*

*breaths deep, cracks knuckles*

more like analgram.

What's this about OF?

Jimjam
09-12-2025, 01:25 AM
I got chewed out by my guild on Lanys for spending DKP gearing up my vox/naggy alt with ntov junk... but that was towards the end of SoL haha.

People just mad - you earned the dkp to spend as you see fit. I doubt your guildies were removing their dkp earned gear while farming non-ToV / SoL content, right?

Knuckle
09-15-2025, 06:05 PM
You will never convince me that even if you had a Time Machine and could travel back in time that you would be able to get BIS from Velious era before Shadows of Luclin dropped ;)

I remember thinking it was absolutely bonkers that my friends TWINK had two blood points and an FBSS, and three pieces of mrylokars in era.

Meanwhile we LARPing that full skyshrine twinks was always the norm. Lmao, I remember people struggling to get full thurg armor on their mains, and spending months raiding plane of growth for armor drops on my own main 😹

Maybe thats because velious is out for 5-10 years longer than live? This server is not going to Luclin so it's a moot point.

tycohunden
09-16-2025, 03:50 AM
that's why we need to add pvp. NO I WONT GO TO RED! I'm too to tired to lvl...

cd288
09-16-2025, 09:45 AM
Maybe thats because velious is out for 5-10 years longer than live? This server is not going to Luclin so it's a moot point.

Just ignore RecondoJoe's ramblings on his new account post-ban

Bisonzabi
09-24-2025, 10:35 PM
It's not classic unless you're using 28.8k-56k dial up connection with a single 15-19in CRT monitor. And the server not going down for random unannounced maintenance.

Knuckle
09-24-2025, 11:40 PM
It's not classic unless you're using 28.8k-56k dial up connection with a single 15-19in CRT monitor. And the server not going down for random unannounced maintenance.

Well also having a packed 2k+ population with minimum game knowledge, so it's always been a fools errand for purists hasn't it.

branamil
09-25-2025, 06:30 PM
If you haven't gotten full BiS including Ring 10, Vulak, Dain, Tormax, and Yelinak loot and then de-leveled to level 1 to level again, you haven't gotten the FULL everquest experience.

kjs86z2
09-26-2025, 09:23 AM
If you haven't gotten full BiS including Ring 10, Vulak, Dain, Tormax, and Yelinak loot and then de-leveled to level 1 to level again, you haven't gotten the FULL everquest experience.

this guy p99s

JayDee
10-05-2025, 02:04 AM
I have thought about that. Maybe the biggest hardcore raiders outside of perhaps the #1 tank or x class of every guild would probably be happy with 2 or 3 bis pieces by the time luclin launches.

And the actual casual raiders? Probably no bis. Meanwhile here everyone even people in the 4th best guild have many bis pieces. Its common for me to inspect people and see they have all bis or missing one or two with a close 2nd best as a placeholder

sammoHung
10-06-2025, 11:22 AM
I have thought about that. Maybe the biggest hardcore raiders outside of perhaps the #1 tank or x class of every guild would probably be happy with 2 or 3 bis pieces by the time luclin launches.

And the actual casual raiders? Probably no bis. Meanwhile here everyone even people in the 4th best guild have many bis pieces. Its common for me to inspect people and see they have all bis or missing one or two with a close 2nd best as a placeholder

I guess the best way to compare it would be to examine gear of the raiders a few months after Velious release, and then again a year after - as the original timeline would have had a Luclin release.

By this time on Green server, following the original timelines releases alongside the Green releases:

Velious (released on Green: July 2021)
Luclin (July 2022)
Planes of Power (May 2023)
Legacy of Ykesha (October 2023)
Lost Dungeons of Norrath (April 2024)
Gates of Discord (September 2024)
Omens of War (April 2025)

These would have all been released by now on Green - had the expansion timeline continued.

Also, Dragons of Norrath would release in November-December 2025.

So, to put it in perspective: Imagine how many BiS toons there'd be if Luclin was delayed for 4.5 years, then you'd maybe see the same amount of BiS toons as you do today.

JayDee
10-06-2025, 01:20 PM
I guess the best way to compare it would be to examine gear of the raiders a few months after Velious release, and then again a year after - as the original timeline would have had a Luclin release.

By this time on Green server, following the original timelines releases alongside the Green releases:

Velious (released on Green: July 2021)
Luclin (July 2022)
Planes of Power (May 2023)
Legacy of Ykesha (October 2023)
Lost Dungeons of Norrath (April 2024)
Gates of Discord (September 2024)
Omens of War (April 2025)

These would have all been released by now on Green - had the expansion timeline continued.

Also, Dragons of Norrath would release in November-December 2025.

So, to put it in perspective: Imagine how many BiS toons there'd be if Luclin was delayed for 4.5 years, then you'd maybe see the same amount of BiS toons as you do today.

I think its even worse than that because a) people had to learn the zones and mobs and mechanics b) probably wiped a lot without voice comms and access to cleric bots ie would sometimes go in with less than optimal composition c) we all sucked most people didnt know basic commands /rt /tt or perhaps even assist macros

I am not sure how long it took for mobs like vulak to to die and by then how consistently it did in just under a year

sammoHung
10-06-2025, 01:28 PM
I think its even worse than that because a) people had to learn the zones and mobs and mechanics b) probably wiped a lot without voice comms and access to cleric bots ie would sometimes go in with less than optimal composition c) we all sucked most people didnt know basic commands /rt /tt or perhaps even assist macros

I am not sure how long it took for mobs like vulak to to die and by then how consistently it did in just under a year

Where I played there was 1 guild that was up-to-date on raid content - and even then, very few had BiS in most of their slots.

But again, people raided Skyshrine back then.

Goregasmic
10-06-2025, 01:55 PM
I have thought about that. Maybe the biggest hardcore raiders outside of perhaps the #1 tank or x class of every guild would probably be happy with 2 or 3 bis pieces by the time luclin launches.

And the actual casual raiders? Probably no bis. Meanwhile here everyone even people in the 4th best guild have many bis pieces. Its common for me to inspect people and see they have all bis or missing one or two with a close 2nd best as a placeholder

Back then I've been in a couple guilds and there was no DKP system in any of them, mostly some form of NBG with officers deciding who gets what. Loot would get dilluted pretty badly.

I guess the best way to compare it would be to examine gear of the raiders a few months after Velious release, and then again a year after - as the original timeline would have had a Luclin release.

By this time on Green server, following the original timelines releases alongside the Green releases:

Velious (released on Green: July 2021)
Luclin (July 2022)
Planes of Power (May 2023)
Legacy of Ykesha (October 2023)
Lost Dungeons of Norrath (April 2024)
Gates of Discord (September 2024)
Omens of War (April 2025)

These would have all been released by now on Green - had the expansion timeline continued.

Also, Dragons of Norrath would release in November-December 2025.

So, to put it in perspective: Imagine how many BiS toons there'd be if Luclin was delayed for 4.5 years, then you'd maybe see the same amount of BiS toons as you do today.

Yeah IIRC during Luclin the top guild was struggling on VT trash and my guild, which was second or third best guild on server, was still struggling on vindi with like 80 people. A lot of guilds did kunark dragons and other bosses but back then there was a gazillion guilds where like, getting a circlet of the falinkan was a serious undertaking. Basically RL friends messing around. Epics were getting more common but not many people were doing cutting edge raiding. P99 players are light years ahead of what live was for the same era.

JayDee
10-06-2025, 02:03 PM
Back then I've been in a couple guilds and there was no DKP system in any of them, mostly some form of NBG with officers deciding who gets what. Loot would get dilluted pretty badly.

.

Loot council which is even worse there would be a couple people on every server with the good shit and even then probably only a few pieces of bis

JayDee
10-06-2025, 02:07 PM
Anecdotal but everyone i know has many BiS pieces some are full bis multiple characters. And they play a few hours every week for quakes or 7 days

DanielStula
10-14-2025, 11:50 PM
I believe that nostalgia plays a crucial role in the enduring popularity of classic emulated servers like Project 1999. Given that many players return to these worlds to recapture their youth, what happens when the memories we cherish clash with the reality of our current gaming expectations? Are we risking the very essence of what made those experiences special by trying to recreate them in a modern context?

Jimjam
10-15-2025, 04:06 AM
What is this wishywasy nothing comment on this thread?

boromn
10-16-2025, 04:40 PM
Nah, what's needed is dynamic content. Constantly change where items drop and how NPC's spawn. It doesn't require constant work either, just need to have an algorithm that automatically shifts everything around. Now the game is a permanent adventure, an Everquest, where nobody knows exactly what will happen and it becomes necessary to hunt throughout every nook and cranny of every zone to see what might be there at any given time.

The only game I can recall playing that actually did this was Asheron's Call. I think it was every month they would change the "migration" patterns of the mobs and old safe areas became dangerous and so forth. Their loot was also pretty much all random anyway. Only a very select items were actual named items. That said, the community in that game was pretty ass since it was mostly solo people exploring the expanse alone. It's why I always bounced back and forth between AC and EQ.

Hasbinbad
11-17-2025, 06:21 PM
My friend got called an ebayer in 2000 because he had FBSS, 2x Lamentation and full crafted on his level 38 warrior
i sold my rogue for $700 in like 2001.. cashed the f out lmao

Wakanda
11-17-2025, 11:28 PM
Yeah IIRC during Luclin the top guild was struggling on VT trash and my guild, which was second or third best guild on server, was still struggling on vindi with like 80 people. A lot of guilds did kunark dragons and other bosses but back then there was a gazillion guilds where like, getting a circlet of the falinkan was a serious undertaking. Basically RL friends messing around. Epics were getting more common but not many people were doing cutting edge raiding. P99 players are light years ahead of what live was for the same era.

Even though I was probably like 15-16 years old at the time, I remember feeling like my parents had wasted money when they bought Scars of Velious because I hardly ever went to the place, was still spending a lot of time in Sol B and Kunark dungeons. I remember vividly looting a Woven Shadow helmet and being super excited about it the night before Luclin launched, and then being excited how it had deer antlers on the new model! Looked completely different than before ! But that's pretty crazy because I was still raiding the Plane of Hate for actual upgrades... when Luclin launched, and I wasn't a small minority on my server. In fact, a lot of people considered me to be the best geared rogue on the server at the time.

I do know shortly after Luclin came out though I did finally start raiding in Velious as the top guild on our server started trying to do VT, leaving NTOV open and what not.

Superfox76
11-18-2025, 04:03 AM
wdym i cant walk into crushbone with 2 sods and a fungi? its classic!

Jimjam
11-18-2025, 07:32 AM
Even though I was probably like 15-16 years old at the time, I remember feeling like my parents had wasted money when they bought Scars of Velious because I hardly ever went to the place, was still spending a lot of time in Sol B and Kunark dungeons. I remember vividly looting a Woven Shadow helmet and being super excited about it the night before Luclin launched, and then being excited how it had deer antlers on the new model! Looked completely different than before ! But that's pretty crazy because I was still raiding the Plane of Hate for actual upgrades... when Luclin launched, and I wasn't a small minority on my server. In fact, a lot of people considered me to be the best geared rogue on the server at the time.

I do know shortly after Luclin came out though I did finally start raiding in Velious as the top guild on our server started trying to do VT, leaving NTOV open and what not.

I don't think I bought Velious until Legacy of Ykesha was out. Definitely I didn't have it by PoP. If I wanted to kill creatures, orcs, gnolls, giants or eaten by a dragon in the snow I had the Halas area! And besides, the sub 40 game was where it was at.

kjs86z2
11-18-2025, 09:14 AM
The only game I can recall playing that actually did this was Asheron's Call. I think it was every month they would change the "migration" patterns of the mobs and old safe areas became dangerous and so forth. Their loot was also pretty much all random anyway. Only a very select items were actual named items. That said, the community in that game was pretty ass since it was mostly solo people exploring the expanse alone. It's why I always bounced back and forth between AC and EQ.

Asheron's Call was vastly superior to EQ in every facet except for "raid" content.

Wakanda
11-19-2025, 08:26 AM
I don't think I bought Velious until Legacy of Ykesha was out. Definitely I didn't have it by PoP. If I wanted to kill creatures, orcs, gnolls, giants or eaten by a dragon in the snow I had the Halas area! And besides, the sub 40 game was where it was at.

Imagine an MMO model in 2025 where major expansion packs were optional, but hardly required, for the vast majority of the player-base. JUST IMAGINE.

WarpathEQ
11-19-2025, 11:04 AM
Doesn't compute to me that it would be possible to continue playing without having the latest expansion considering those droppable items made their way into the market.

But yeah back in classic live I only stepped foot in antonica and kunark, never went to velious and played through Luclin and I believe PoP release (stopped when there was a large exodus of people after EQ2 and WoW were announced/released).

Back then I never guilded. Naggy and Vox were open raids for all 52s on server which were organized by a handful of folks (that I assisted with). I remember a Vox raid taking a couple of hours typically from when Vox spawned until the word got out accross the server that anyone with a 52 should head over to permafrost, then clearing basically the entire zone so we didn't train ourselves, then spending prolly 30 minutes in OOC/Shout spewing out raid instructions to everyone, then going in and making an attempt.

I was able to complete my entire bard epic minus phinny which was really only being killed by raiding guilds with 1-2 groups of people and the loot was still rare enough that they weren't entertaining any type of loot right or MQ opportunity for a tagless bard.

Wakanda
11-19-2025, 10:11 PM
Asheron's Call was vastly superior to EQ in every facet except for "raid" content.I don't want to bash AC since I never played it, but the reason I'm going to lean towards this being inaccurate is because I knew several people IRL who bought Asheron's Call after playing EQ and they all quit AC within 2 weeks and came back to EQ despite never raiding in EQ.

kjs86z2
11-20-2025, 07:52 AM
I don't want to bash AC since I never played it, but the reason I'm going to lean towards this being inaccurate is because I knew several people IRL who bought Asheron's Call after playing EQ and they all quit AC within 2 weeks and came back to EQ despite never raiding in EQ.

ya if you quit AC in 2 weeks you didnt play the game - thats like bashing orcs naked and coming back and saying eq sucks

i played AC from early 2000 to 2005...was a heck of a lot better than anything p99

Ponzini
11-20-2025, 02:44 PM
I enjoy this game 100x more just playing with self found gear

Wakanda
11-20-2025, 09:17 PM
ya if you quit AC in 2 weeks you didnt play the game - thats like bashing orcs naked and coming back and saying eq sucks

i played AC from early 2000 to 2005...was a heck of a lot better than anything p99

I didn't play it. Never claimed to. I just know the people who did told me it was bad and discouraged me from even trying it when I was at their house. Stating that it sucked compared to EQ. And 2 weeks / half a subscription is more than enough time to tell if you like an MMO. In fact, that's generally the time period where most new MMOs fail. If you play something for 14 days and don't like it, odds are that playing it for another 5 months isn't going to suddenly fix the game for you.

Keep in mind while I never tried AC during that time period, I did try a handful of other MMOs and was able to tell relatively fast that they weren't jack compared to EQ. Anarchy Online is another prime example of this. Should I have played for another 6 months even though I found the game boring and lacking within hours of logging into it?

Something I never had a problem with EQ, WoW, Rift, even Pantheon or MnM. You don't need to force yourself to play a game you don't enjoy for months to realize it's good. It's either good or isn't.

That being said I do know a lot of people loved AC. Reckful actually started on AC. So do I think it's actual dog scat? Obvsly not. I just don't think it was overwhelmingly superior to EQ if people who played both games chose EQ instead. I also don't think if AC was overwhelmingly superior that they would have churned out an AC 2 a couple of years later.

It could also be that a person's first MMO will always hold a special place in heart. A lot of my younger friends talk about WoW the same way I talk about EQ. And ironically, a lot of them actually started WoW during a time period that historically is unpopular (cataclysm for instance), but since it was their first MMO experience, it will always hold a special place in their heart. I imagine this is similar for EQ, UO, DAOC and AC players.

I do know one thing about AC, apparently the PvP was dramatically better. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mUvcSts322I) Again one of the best PvPers in WoW history got his start in AC and the PvP looked intense. Something that Rallos Zek didn't really have. Very little mechanics comparatively etc.

kjs86z2
11-24-2025, 12:02 PM
That being said I do know a lot of people loved AC. Reckful actually started on AC. So do I think it's actual dog scat? Obvsly not. I just don't think it was overwhelmingly superior to EQ if people who played both games chose EQ instead. I also don't think if AC was overwhelmingly superior that they would have churned out an AC 2 a couple of years later.

It could also be that a person's first MMO will always hold a special place in heart. A lot of my younger friends talk about WoW the same way I talk about EQ. And ironically, a lot of them actually started WoW during a time period that historically is unpopular (cataclysm for instance), but since it was their first MMO experience, it will always hold a special place in their heart. I imagine this is similar for EQ, UO, DAOC and AC players.

I do know one thing about AC, apparently the PvP was dramatically better. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mUvcSts322I) Again one of the best PvPers in WoW history got his start in AC and the PvP looked intense. Something that Rallos Zek didn't really have. Very little mechanics comparatively etc.


Yep, I played with Byron quite a bit in the early era. His character was Anti Parazi and he was well known as one of the best mages.

Mage "war" spells could be dodged. Mages could control the timing of their casts and when they spells would release (faster, delayed, etc) with certain movements that would break animation. Archer missile attacks could be dodged.

The PvP mechanics were the best any MMO has ever seen, period. Guilds would battle over the best XP/loot spots.

You die you drop items, but you could protect yourself from dropping your gear by having very high value items (they were called "Death Items"). If you died too much without restocking (expensive if you were protecting very good gear) you could lose your gear, looted by the person who did the most damage to you.

Pretty classic mage pvp play here:

licH1H31kF0