Originally Posted by captnamazing (Post 2099278)

Originally Posted by Legday (Post 2099279)

The way its done in Asgard is that if you get an upgrade to a dropable item won via DKP, you should (and this usually happens) give the old item to someone who can use it or to the guild bank.

The difference here is that if somebody leaves Asgard while wearing dropable DKP won loot, it's never, ever, asked to be returned.

This thread is riddled with bad examples, so for some reason we are talking about upgrades while still in guild.

Originally Posted by Kagey (Post 2099285)

difference is we don't need to ask, we don't recruit lootwhores.

Originally Posted by Legday (Post 2099287)

ton of examples

Originally Posted by dafier (Post 2099293)

The items I've given back to the guild after winning them and passing them on, I've never experienced an officer saying:

/tell Rebbon Glorious sir, please allow us to have XXX pixels back since you are going to replace them with XXX pixels. Does this upset you?

Originally Posted by Spyder73 (Post 2099253)

I win Tear of Quellis

Originally Posted by Legday (Post 2099303)

Yeah, like I said, we do that too.

Originally Posted by fiveeauxfour (Post 2099304)

ahahaha

i think tekilya is just testing the waters to see if bda couldnt get him a tear faster; he has been looking for one for quite a while. As a dps its like his most sought after item. If he bothered to put in any effort in his char to get a key he could probably snag some hosh boots faster, but who cares. Yo, i think bda's loot rules looked fine you should join them, tek, you would have a better shot at a tear there

Originally Posted by Kagey (Post 2099285)

we don't recruit lootwhores.