From my understanding isle 1 and 1.5 don't fall under raid agreements, which is why Sirfloppy was permitted to take so many Efreeti?

I remember him once accuse us from stealing one of his rots (Weight of the Gods) that he wanted to sell rights to. We were farming Spiroc Lord at the time, and he had just left his corpse timer to tick too long.

I mean (falsely) threatening to petition over a WotG while he was invading sky on another guild's slot. Was pretty hilarious.

P99 truly is a magical kingdom.

I think if P99 were actually a money-maker, staff would approach it with a very different business sense...

mad double post:
I now see 1.5 doesn't count as raid mobs but it still counts as raid zone.

Should change that.

Let me get this straight, a simple IP search would show that a NON core member logged into a core member tagged character and it gave core an extended raid ban? This could be very, very easily abused if that’s the case and something we should avoid at all costs...

Also there is the spirit of the rule vs letter of the law. If the monk was core I could see it being upheld, if the monk is some random getting help by some good guys, come on...

Good luck policing every guild member ever when people take breaks weeks/months at a time, and pay various amounts of attention to things. Just ban the individual member for 7 days whenever they violate the rule if you want to be so extreme about it. Then they'll be forced to ask guild/read rules during their ban and learn. Banning an entire guild for 30 days for someone zoning into a raid zone and killing a minor non-raid target blows my mind. Then again raid scene is already crazy extreme, might as well double down on the craziness, can't go wrong doing that.

You are correct. What's crazy is this happened twice both resulting in non-rescinded suspension extensions for <Core>. ( they were appealed obviously but to no success )

Yes Staff are aware for the first 2 extensions that a <Tempest> member for the first and a Random player not affiliated with Core for the second logged into inactive <Core> accounts.

Until you stop logging in, nothing will change...