More people trying to bully #1 out of the list?

I'm far too casual for this list nonsense or anything requiring more than 2-3 hours of effort, but as a hypothetical example:

#1 is a level 35 ranger, so meets the requirements for the list despite having the damage output of a level 14 druid and a level 21 rogue combined

#1 must participate in the kill

#1 is pissing fluorescent red into a nearby bucket from the amount of energy drinks he has consumed over the last 129 hours

#1 has a verbal agreement with everyone there that they will help now that it's his turn

#1 winds up and attacks the mob, everyone else (may or may not be his own guildmates) hangs around there FD or hidden, laughing.

#1 gets one-shot by the riposte from his first swing, ranger gates, and is out of range, losing his place on the list

#1 receives tell from Myuharin saying "HAHAHAHA THAT WAS HILARIOUS"

Would this scenario be petition-able as well by #1?

If not, this is wide open for griefing (it can and will happen, you know the sort of people that play here).

Agree. And saying no doesn't make me a jerk.


Because it is easy I am expected to do it? This is entitlement. No one gets to tell me how to feel but me.

That's actually the core problem between the two camps of thought. One just want's everyone to get along and sing "kumbaya" and not worry about loot, just enjoy the experience. The other wants people to carry their own weight. Threads like this is what happens when these two people intersect.

Sweet, I'll make sure to get a therapist and tell him internet-dude diagnosed me.

please, tell us more about how your masturbatory Randian objectivist fantasies aren't being fulfilled by everquest

I'm too low still and haven't /listed yet, but maybe something like was done on live when Fabled drops were happening could work here.

Make the group that kills the camp be the listed players 1-6. Lists were manually kept during that time and players were cycled into the group as persons got the item and left. If it is done based on list position, everyone can see who should be in the group and it can be verified. A 6 man group of melee or caster or healer or whatever should be able to drop the PH and friends.

If someone violates the rules of 1-6 being in the group, GM removes them from the list or ports them out.

This bumps XP groupers from the camps, but it doesn't sound like anyone would go to XP there anyway knowing their drops will go to /listers.

There are details to this that would have to be discussed and I'm sure some loophole might be found, but it worked back then with Fabled items, it could make sense here too.

Nishoba / Coldstep - Blue
Phaded / Glorified - Green

lot of good input here

but the reality is the list system works fine if there isn't just 1 or 2 people at a camp that cant take down the mob. we're quickly moving into an era where ph's breathe for all but a few seconds before they're downed

still a jerk move to not help if you're on the list, but that's just my opinion i guess

what is this

Onward to the deepest levels of forumquest!

This is dumb

Automatic account deletion after 48 hours on the list, for the player's own good.