Why not keep pumices in, but price them accordingly?

I'm in favor of keeping things as simple as possible. Making up new mechanics for broken stuff is not as simple as removing broken stuff. Removing egg pumice is kinda half-classic because they were removed fairly early on live. Making them lore, one charge, super expensive or neon green is far less classic.

Will sow pots be makable?

On beta, my mage had about 100 plat by level 10 and that was from exp mobs, wasn't even really farming for cash. That would have been over 1000 plat with 10x less exp.

A level 4 enchanter can run stein of moggok 3 times and have over 1000 plat.

I'm sorry you're bad.

Yup.

Lethdar and Co. just want pumice out of the game so they can farm more pixels (Golem Wands), then get raid buffed, and go around ganking fools 6v2.

Imo, pumice makes the shit more fair.
Guy with raid buffs jumps you. Roots pet, DoTs you. You blow 1 pumice ripping snare off pet, DoT off yourself. Then 2 or 3 more on him. Suddenly its even, you vs him w/o any buffs.

God forbid people have to change their games accordingly.

It's pretty generally accepted that instant pumice ruins pvp, and that's why they were removed.

From the lively discussion, it's pretty apparent in this thread that it isn't generally accepted.

Generally accepted has nothing to do with whether or not it should be in game~

Bending to the will of forum trolls does not improve gameplay.

Actually, I think we're on the same side, Envious. I was (badly) stating that pumice ruining pvp wasn't generally accepted.

Siding with the trolls, insta-cast pumice pels are lame.