Hadden
 

12 hadden's in a row with no earring. Couple times no fishing pole either and no earring. Seems like a bug to me. Could someone at least double check the code for this.

More data points: I've seen at least one "no pole, nothing else" spawn myself recently, and have talked to others that have also. No one has seen an earring lately (lately == past three days or so, on Green).

16 in a row with no earring... multiple times with no fishing pole either.

When I camped him on green it took 12 or 14 spawns, and that was after I "inherited" the camp from a guy that had been there for at least that long without getting a drop either.

-Mcoy

Should be 25% chance of dropping, 1 in 4, so multiple people are getting less than 25% odds, seems like a bug to me.

17 in a row no earring

just buy it lol

unless your one of those guys who farm like 80 items and spam the EC tunnel with like

60 items

Finally got it on the 18th try... I still say something ain't right.

If the mob is spawning, then the loot table is working.

You're just a victim of bad luck.