Upper Guk live Froglok faction wrong?
 

As a HE shouldn't I be indifferent to UGuk by default? Having never been in zone before this, I haven't killed any frogs and yet I'm KOS. Is there anything else that could affect faction, or is this a bug?

what's your religion?

Ah yes... Erolissi Marr. I'm guessing that's the difference.

90% sure all start out dubiously with live frogs, as it no matter whatever char I've had that killed in uguk, only took 10 min to get kos

Your HE (Half elf? High Elf? does not matter) who worships Erollsi should not even be close to KOS with the Frogs of Guk. Live Frogs are a good aligned race and only start KOS with evil races/classes/religions.

Run a newly made Erollsi worshiper out there and you will see its not KOS. My guess is you must of done something to make them hate you.

I don't have the exact numbers where on the list you are, but most likely all good char's will be mid between kos and appr, as all good chars start out dubious to live frogs. I very much doubt they considder any good race/deity combo better than others

Frogs arent that smart ... they're just barely able to see the diff of good and bad :)