Fleshy Orbs (Qeynos, Priestess Caulria) seems broken
 

Turned in the Fleshy Orb just now and she ate it - not returned, no dialogue, money, exp, anything. The wiki page says amiable faction is required for completion, and I am currently amiable.

I'd advise how to reproduce but she ate the orb :/

Now THIS I can fap to!!!

You turned in Fleshy Orb which would identify as [Odd Tumor Returned].

Caulria wants the Fleshy Orbs dropped by rabid wolves. [Odd Tumor]

It seems as though you turned in the proper item, she gave you back the returned item, and you tried to turn it in again.

Hmm, I definitely only remember turning in one Fleshy Orb but this scenario would certainly make sense with the outcome. I am familiar with the quest and that she returns a similar, but different, item for delivery to Freeport.

Even so though, shouldn't I have received experience, dialogue, faction etc. upon the first turn-in? I had nothing in my game logs of the sort...

you dont get experience for the first part, perhaps not even faction, you def get some dialog tho

This works fine as far as I can see. At 2014-06-06 18:24:13, you received the [Odd Tumor]. Then, 2014-06-11 16:10:31 you turned it in, to receive nothing.

Note, the orbs quest was previously not giving any exp, and that is fixed, pending update.