What I would love to see is a rotation new server :3 One that is set up to reset every year or so....BUT, when it resets, all characters are moved to the main p1999 server.

That way anyone who wants the "new server experience" could join the server that cycles itself....while still allowing people to keep their characters and join the late game server.

As has been said...even if you reset the main server, after a year the server will be farmed / twinked out anyway. The ONLY way to keep giving people that classic fresh option is to keep resetting (but that punishes casual gamers and people who really become attached to their characters). A 2 server system makes everyone happy.

((If you really want to get fancy, don't just wipe the rotation server....and give people an option to move their characters to the 1999 server or "rebirth" their characters on the rotation server. If they choose to rebirth and are higher than level 50, then they get a legacy title? Or some other badge of honor?))

Yeah I agree. I liked Luclin. And AAs gave reason to still use old zones. But PoP basically made the entire rest of the game useless.

Of course it's academic because no one will make a Luclin server anytime soon and certainly not nilbog.

No resets. Not classic! The whole point in waking up the Sleeper is to experience Norrath afterwards.

Ok I will admit my ignorance on this. I was only on live until about 6 months tops after velious was released. I had no idea what the sleeper actually was. After having read the description on the wiki, I would like to change my vote. This sounds pretty awesome to me.
Again, I was ignorant to this particular part of eq history. Please flame me to the appropriate degree. Thank you.

Except no.

PoP was the greatest expansion. Subscriptions proved it. Reviews proved it. Lore proved it. Content proved it.

Best quests, raids and group content were available in PoP. It was also a culmination where you had conquered dragons and aliens, time to face the gods themselves. The expansion had something like 110~ Separate raid/multi-group events. Nothing else really comes close to that level of depth.

It is when tradeskills really took off in viability and worth. Probably also the point when balance was pretty damn near perfect. Wizards were excellent in groups and raids. Druids could now effectively heal most anywhere. Rangers were totally boss with bow damage and pretty formidable with melee. It took the weakest classes in groups and made everything more balanced between new spells and AAs.

People bitch and moan about PoK books. But those same people refuse to run from EC to Ro and require a Druid port. Bunch of hypocrits. And don't try to pull the interacting with players card, PoP required it just as much as classic. You needed help to get your keys and flags. Needed help to finish quests, get rezzes, do tradeskills, etc.

PoP confirmed best expansion.

Man this Daldaen guy is like my long lost EverQuest twin. PoP was the greatest MMO expansion of all time. It was the first expansion that actually made tradeskills worth something. It finally realized a clear progression path for casual players and raiders via elemental armor and ornate armor. It had the elite feeling of locked zones via difficult content both raid and group. Amazing music, graphics, and you felt the true lore of Everquest in every zone you went into, culminating in the amazing plane of time. Anyone who hates PoP hates EverQuest IMO.

True, PoP was one of the least worst expansioms

Crypt of Decay, the amazing music and ambiance. Solsek Ro tower. Bastion of Thunder. plane of earth. The amazing earring tradeskill quest, power of the elements quest, epic boss models, I could go on forever. Man PoP was so fucking good.

This.

There's a reason I rolled on Mac server. Cause PoP was the shit. Grimel Earring, Secrets of Power, Power of Elements, Planar tradeskills (Baking, Brewing, Fletching, Pottery all finally useful. Blacksmithing, Jewelcrafting, and Fletching even more useful). You want hard single group content, Elementals / ToSR/ BoT Towers got you covered. You want casual 2-3 group content, Paffa (CoD), Vhaskiz / Hobgoblin ring / Hedge Event / Mujaki (PoN), Bee Event / Fort Bosses (PoStorm), Tower bosses (BoT) got you covered. You want raids... The WHOLE flagging scripts got your back.

You want kiting zones, got it. Dungeon crawls, check. Standard tank and spank camps, they're there.

PoP confirmed best expansion ever.

god > pop imho