Tarnished Weapon + Water Flask = Small Piece of Ore?
 

Am I remember it wrong or can you not combine a Tarnished Weapon and a Water Flask in a Forge to make Small Pieces of Ore?

This combine was post-classic.

Ah. That explains it.

Thanks!

Try hitting up Allakhazam circa 2000 or so on the Internet Archive for a reliable list of classic blacksmithing (and other tradeskill) combines. Only catch is that it's often slow as fuck. The P99 Wiki has some information as well.