This is dumb, you guys should feel bad.

I dunno - sounds more like a pro, than a con.

Long / harsh punishments are good. Server for too long has been a "Shoot first, ask forgiveness later" type of mentality.

People should be incredibly careful of raid pulls instead of "lul whoops sorry".

Won't be that simple.

The Norrathian Court precedent states that a name change will not be sufficient to wipe past transgressions and reset any penalty stacking. The new guild must be materially different with a substantial (~50%) change in both membership and leadership.

Case #66269, Forsaken vs. Rampage, 2015

100% this.

"Save Us from CSG Petitions"

Thanks for confirmation. So you did kill it. Great.

This situation... this suspension length... the offender... the victim(s)... yikes.

Yes reasonable of course, but its a risk that GuildA is taking knowing that they cannot properly 'deal' ( train away, kill it, or manipulate it in anyway ) with the conceded mob should GuildB have some trouble with it. Puts GuildA in such an awkward spot that shit could negatively affect them if an unexpected issue occurs. Sometimes its best to just be cautious and not be in harms way when there looks to be something harmful manifesting right next to you.

Root them all