Quote:
Originally Posted by knix
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
With the 1 1 1 rotation plan there is times where on a repop there will be an R mob that spawns. For example the R mob would be gorenaire. The R -guild who was assigned that spawn would have to go after that gorenaire first before competing for other FFA mobs. You will not be able to go after FFA mobs if your R mobs spawns. There might be 2 or 3 R mobs that spawn on a repop day.
Who is going to police this, are you going to expect Sirken and Derubael to monitor this to make sure R's are doing it right? And what happens to the R guild if they go after an FFA mob while they have a R spawned, or what happens to a C guild if they kill a mob on a repop day honestly thinking its an FFA or a C mob.
|
I believe it was brought up in the Raid Discussion that Rogean was able to create something that would collect who killed what, and then upload that to a site (similar to whokilledit), which would let everyone know which class was the last to kill the mob. It would give a reliable way to know which mobs are locked to which tier.
Further, the 1/1/1 split doesn't necessarily mean that the Class R guilds have to rotate. Rogean's plan only says that Class R guilds cannot monopolize a single mob, by needing to wait 2 respawns until their next claim. Any agreement between the Class R guilds, and the challenges (such as getting your assigned Class R mob before a FFA spawned mob) fall entirely on Class R and the way they decide to manage their system. That isn't the responsibility of Rogean's Plan to institute such a rotation, only to make it so each side can create their own environment that is beneficial to themselves, without degrading the other.
So, as for who is going to police this, it will be rather simple to police in truth. You look at the schedule, it was a Class C mob, a Class R guild did it, swap the loot, done. There's no question as to who is in the wrong in this case, because we know the Class R guild was the aggressor. No need to delve through endless crap to discover the truth. Class R guild takes out a Class C mob, they are in trouble, end.
As for enforcing whatever Class R sets up among themselves, that's on themselves to create a system to manage it. Rogean's Plan doesn't force a rotation on either side, so if Class R creates a rotation, it's on them to live up to it, and to find a way to enforce it, because that was created by them. Without a rotation, the 2 kill lockout for Class R is more than enough to help diffuse a single guild from being insanely too powerful and monopolizing.