Quote:
Originally Posted by Eponymous Anonymous
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
With Sev, AG got an accidental FTE with their tracker, who was then disqualified and thus had to concede the encounter, and so there was no rightful FTE in this case. The situations are vastly different and I don't see the first setting a precedent for the second.
|
The precedent is what Sirken said multiple times in that thread and that is that the ONLY time to kill a raid mob is when YOU have FTE. He also said specifically that FTE should have been allowed to reset.
The situation is actually quite similar. 2 guilds got on the FTE list and the guild that got FTE had their person die and the guild that also was on the list killed the dragon without their own FTE. That was the essence of that whole thread. IB decided that TMO's FTE didn't count and killed the mob. Taken decided that AG's FTE didn't count and killed the mob. That's very similar. You have 2 guilds both getting on the agro list without FTE. you have 2 guilds deciding on their own that the FTE didn't count and killing the mob.
Bottom line is that Taken should get a week off. Sirken specifically warned everyone in the raid discussion forum.