[Issar]

My warrior experience is limited to being twinked. With the right gear you make the best damage absorbing tank and you pull really good DPS. This does require cash though. Threat is highly dependent on gear.

Pally imo, is the best group tank. The hold aggro with ease, they can cc in the form of root, they have stuns for interruptions and added hate, they can lull decently, and they can heal and do so quite well. LoH will save group members in a pinch and can often prevent wipes when things do get messy.

SK's are pure awesome. They hold aggro as well as a pally, they can FD pull, have a cess to instant invis clicky, and can solo efficiently albeit slowly. They're also pure evil, which is always fun to play.

I guess one other note on a warrior is that you really are limited in options i.e. no spells, not many buttons to mash. This is a game changer for some.

Between SK and Pally, it's really just a difference in playstyle. I played a pally on P99 and hAve really enjoyed the class. I played an SK twink in the velious Era of live and loved that I could effectively tank and solo.