I have a 35 sk and a 57 shaman. Both leveled with a Fungi, HP gear, haste item, and a good weapon.
The shaman is LOADS more powerful than a SK when given heavy regen and twinked. At 35 on the SK I can tank CE in MM fine. At 35 on the Shaman I had a Fungi stick AND a Fungi tunic (they stack. Stick clicks at 35). So I was tanking (with slow) AND healing CE in MM.
Once I hit 40 or so on the SK I'll move the fungi back to the shaman. I have a 58 Paladin. I like the SK too and I'll be taking it to the 50s at the very least.
But if you're only looking at sk vs shaman with a fungi (and potentially a fungi stick) the shaman wins outright.
|