Quote:
Originally Posted by AenorVZ
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Is the door still open for the show to do R+L=D, B+A=J?
|
heh no, the show has 100% closed the door on R+L=J, and since that was the question that GRRM asked D&D before he agreed to let them do the show, i have a hard time accepting it will be different in the books.
as for A+B=anything, when exactly would this have happened? Lyanna is "abducted" in or near 282AC and so Brandon (with his squire and a few other nerds) goes to King's Landing demanding that Rhaegar come out to die, but instead is arrested. Aerys summons the fathers of these men to Kings Landing to answer for their son's "crimes". Rickard (Brandon's father) goes to KL to get his son and is also arrested. Shortly after that, both men are killed by Aerys (with the help of fire and a choking device).
All we actually know for sure is that Ashara was in Harrenhal in 281AC and back in Starfall by the end of Robert's Rebellion in 283AC, where she "killed herself" after Eddard arrives with Dawn and news of Ser Arthur Dayne. And we are
pretty sure that Ashara was Pregnant and either had the baby, or lost the baby near around the same time that Ned did this.
we also know that the taking of Gulltown was at or near the end of 282AC, and that the rebellion lasted about a year. Literally the only chance Ashara and Brandon had of hooking up within a time period to produce Jon or Dany would be for the few days that Brandon is in the black cells.
its actually much more likely that FAegon is Ashara's son than anything else. Dany was born on Dragonstone near the end of the war, Aerys' wife (Queen Rhaella) died giving birth to Dany, and shortly after a family friend helped them across the narrow sea to Essos. furthermore, I strongly believe that Septa Lemore could actually be Ashara Dayne, which would farther explain why shes in the Aegon camp should that be her son.
A+B could not have realistically happened in 282AC. and in my opinion R+L can only = J at this point.