[Rygar]

Appreciate your feedback PaulG, while i agree on some of your points I disagree on others.

For example, i don't think it is fair to dismiss his tracking and description of the spawn timer and come to the conclusion that he "had no idea what he is talking about". The info comes first hand from this guy who had clearly done the quest before, and by his own words has "made it his mission" to figure out the spawn timer. He is not repeating what he heard, clearly it is what he witnessed.

Really, the alternative "evidence" I've seen is one post claiming she is 10 hours, another claiming 10-12. No details, no specifics, no claims that they personally witnessed it, etc. I think the monkly business post is the most reliable we have to work with (unless someone can show differently).

I do agree that some of the respawn dynamics might be questionable about spawn vs hand-in, but history has shown there is a more than a few weird spawn dynamics in EQ (Pyzin, Raster of Guk, Stormfeather, Lodizal, etc). I just feel the monk would have been able to tell the difference. I'm thinking of he had high confidence on the window, he would have had friends and guildies pre-park there on at least a few occasions for a quick hand in, in which case he would give a shorter window if it really was 10 hours (obviously no one can prove that though, just conjecture).

Also not sure what you were talking about the half life of the window needing to be different, thought i wrote that out clearly showing he factored in the 30 minute variance. Where is my math off specifically? Maybe it is, and I'm just having a brain fart.