Person #2 is not wrong, but he
is an asshole.
edit to clarify: The precedent set (
http://wiki.project1999.com/Camp_Rules) does not make any mention of a list, just that he's campable and you don't need to stick around afk for 6 hours to do it. The camp rules also 'state' that the person currently holding the camp can hand it over to anyone he wants, but he has to name a name when asked.