https://web.archive.org/web/20041014....shtml?zone=42
“Pirate Island: There is a single Pirate on an island right west of the the Erollisi Island. He was red at level 17 and aggressive. One of the Mudtoe Ogres can sometimes be found here. On the Island there is also a shopkeeper selling Magician spells.”
“ a pirate
A pirate popped where the AC spawns, but he's not listed as being on the bestiary. Any idea why he's there?“
“RE: a pirate
He is a place-holder for the Ancient Cyclops.“
https://web.archive.org/web/20040823....shtml?id=3452
“Ocean of Tears AC
On top of the steep Pirate Island is an old tower, with a spell vendor inside. Stand in the arched entry to the tower interior, then look south. You will be looking at a corner of fence. If you climb the fence, you can imagine the corner as an arrow. It points past a dead tree toward a blunt finger of sand sticking out into the water. That finger of land is the only spawn spot on the island (except for the vendor). The AC will spawn there. So will Boog Mudtoe, regular cyclopses, the pirate and - for me, just before the AC spawned - low-level aqua goblins. “
I think it is confirmed what are the ph and only those ph and the vendor spawn there.
Unconfirmed all/which mobs pathed. I feel like boog was often just sat on the coast but this is pretty likely a false memory.