Well technically this is about the class that benefits the most from gear upgrades from 1-60, so monk is out because naked the monk is pretty powerful so it doesn't benefit as much from gear as the warrior or ranger. Warriors too are stronger naked than a ranger I would guess.
However rangers have spells! So they are certainly more powerful than a warrior naked.
And the other tank classes have spells and even full heals and HT's so they are more powerful than a warrior naked.
Now that we have that settled, that warrior is the weakest naked and therefore gets the most benefit from gear upgrades at the get go, warrior is the clear winner here.
However we should also just make sure that the top end benefits of the gear at 60 for a class don't have a greater impact for the other classes than a top gear warrior .
Warriors do however have some pretty amazing top end gear and so that means that I think they still win out overall, as the class that benefits the most form gear upgrades from 1-60, and monks, casters, and hybrids benifit the least.
But the scribe argument is pretty much take all I think if it's allowed.
|