https://wiki.project1999.com/Fish_Dinner
According to Wiki, this is broken.
https://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/...html?quest=644
Fresh Fish + Spear should work.
Roary Fishpouncer says, 'Rrrrr... I need both the spear and a frrresh fish to prrrepare the spear with the oil.'
Roary Fishpouncer says, 'Rrrr... been doing some deepwater fishing, I presume? Here is your spear with a frrresh coat of my special oil.'