Quote:
Originally Posted by YendorLootmonkey
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Sure, right after everyone on Inny's hate list from this encounter is suspended:
http://www.project1999.org/forums/sh...1&postcount=88
You got the DT and then no one had Inny aggro. Not you, not your guild. Inny was re-engaged by Perun and because you didn't have a tagger ready after you took the DT, the next TMO to engage was 9 seconds after Perun. This precedence of "the first guild to take the DT does not have FTE because they do not take and hold aggro" was set back here by Rogean himself:
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Or should we go with banning whichever TMO enchanter mem-blurred Talendor on us at 2%?
It is. Perhaps you should stop neglecting the rules when it suits you to do so:
http://www.project1999.org/forums/sh...ad.php?t=14667
The problem from our perspective is that you are operating by some other set of rules other than the ones currently in effect. Mem-blurring Talendor at 2%? Raid interference. Conveniently declaring Phinny a non-raid mob so you can skirt around the 15-man rule? Rules-lawyering. And we're just supposed to sit there and be a doormat? LOL.
I have no problems with GMs/Guides taking a heavy-handed approach to punishment, for EVERY guild. The more that punishment is doled out, the less acceptable the behavior will become for any guild. Especially if they suspend the violator and the innocent guildmate next to him. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] Again, let peer pressure sort that shit out within the suspended player's guild. |
The 15man rule was thrown away with the new raid agreement.
Phinigal has been 3-4manned since prekunark times, hardly a raid target by any means.
Amelinda declared it a camp on the spot, we showed proof that ib/vd showed up late. IB/VD KS'd after and nothing happened.
Any other thing you want to bring up, go ahead, but you can't beat clear cut violation of rules more than what was presented with Phinny.
If what you're saying is that you justify KS'n Phinny due to the other stuff, then i'll so be it. Don't start crying when shit really gets dirty tho.