You really think you should have the same hit/miss rate as a 20-30+ just because both of you may fight a mob 5 levels lower than you?
I don't think you give weapon skill enough credit then. You should miss a ton because you suck at your weapon skill regardless of what the mob cons to you, because it takes BOTH.
I think its incoming damage from npcs that is the problem, not melee's offensive abilities which may or may not be a little bit off. I believe something is fishy with AC. No proof though. I haven't seen a raid yet, but it seems tanks take more damage here, even twinked ones. <<total opinion