Unfortunately a lot of the old sites are truly gone, even from the Wayback machine. This is especially true for forum sites, but it may be true for Everlore also.
Lots of old sites used the same forum system, and that forum system added a "no robots" entry because for whatever reason they didn't want Google spidering their forum posts. Wayback machine respects that entry, so it won't show archived material from sites with it. As a result tons of old forums chock-filled with great EQ info are now truly gone.
So yeah unless you can find the original Everlore guy you're probably out of luck. It's too bad so much great EQ material has been lost to time.
EDIT: Actually it looks like Wayback
does have Everlore:
https://web.archive.org/web/20041001...*/everlore.com ... does that not have what you need?