Quest Issue: Rephas's Rat Ear Pie (& ArcaneScientists faction)

[Brut]

After turning in some dozen stacks of rat ears, Rephas has decided that I cannot get any better with ArcaneScientists. Altho he's still threateningly to me ogre SK (DE mask makes it dubiously). =(

According to commenter in Alla, Ikky monk can get up to kindly doing this:
http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/q...03006454591985

Also claims he got from kos to dubious in a few stacks, Imma turned in probably 20+ stacks of em (+ few stacks of giant rat ears) to get this far.

Also, when you give Rephas a regular rat ear, he gives you a Grilled Rat Ear, you give the Grilled Rat Ear back, Rephas gives fish scales 100%. Commenter above claims that's 2/3 reward, this guy suggests you get Tattered Sandals. Some other guys mention spell scrolls, but hard to guess which scrolls. Fish scales likely reward, sandals less likely methinks. Someone says "ranger scroll" but again, no idea what spells those are.