Raid Scene (the 5%)

[Xerical]

I have been playing EQ on P99 for about 5 months now. When I first joined everyone said the best time I will have is leveling up and experiencing content outside of raids because raiding on P99 is a shit-show. I remember EQ classic and I figured they meant training/KSn. Then I got 60 and realized its no where near that... its 10x worse. And reading the posts about ideas of fixing it, seems like Sirken/Deru foster the environment in a manner that is fitting to the 5%, and not the 95% (of raiders). They encourage this style of 'who has the most neckbeards, and of them who actually has the longest hair?'. After all, it doesn't matter what the variance is. The variance is just the guide to the above ^, how long does xxx neckbeard need to stand at yyy spawn point. I would stop there and just say damn, guess this server is just for the 5%... but then I read a post from Rogean and have hope.
http://www.project1999.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=131586

'We are all here for competition, but it needs to be fair competition'.
'Not providing the server to give people the arena to compete to such bitter extremes'

Right now you either join IB/TMO and let a few individuals dedicate their life to getting targets for 99% of their guild. Or you join Class-R and see a raid target once every 2-3 months. Is there really no solution to make the game more enjoyable for the majority of the population? Playing EQ is great, but not like this.

[Nirgon]

Need examples of more than 2 guilds farming VP during Kunark era on live

to care

[Xerical]

Originally Posted by Nirgon [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Need examples of more than 2 guilds farming VP during Kunark era on live

to care

I am fine with two guilds ruling over VP at this stage in EQ (Kunark). It's justifiable. Everything else, no.

[nyclin]

Originally Posted by Nirgon [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Need examples of more than 2 guilds farming VP during Kunark era on live

to care

every single live server would likely have had more than 2 guilds raiding VP after 3 years of kunark, but since no live server ever saw 3 years of kunark, we'll never know

comparing p99 to live is false equivalency at this point; no server was as top-heavy as p99, and there were literally no guilds that had the resources that TMO/IB do

[fastboy21]

Originally Posted by Xerical [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I have been playing EQ on P99 for about 5 months now. When I first joined everyone said the best time I will have is leveling up and experiencing content outside of raids because raiding on P99 is a shit-show. I remember EQ classic and I figured they meant training/KSn. Then I got 60 and realized its no where near that... its 10x worse. And reading the posts about ideas of fixing it, seems like Sirken/Deru foster the environment in a manner that is fitting to the 5%, and not the 95% (of raiders). They encourage this style of 'who has the most neckbeards, and of them who actually has the longest hair?'. After all, it doesn't matter what the variance is. The variance is just the guide to the above ^, how long does xxx neckbeard need to stand at yyy spawn point. I would stop there and just say damn, guess this server is just for the 5%... but then I read a post from Rogean and have hope.
http://www.project1999.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=131586

'We are all here for competition, but it needs to be fair competition'.
'Not providing the server to give people the arena to compete to such bitter extremes'

Right now you either join IB/TMO and let a few individuals dedicate their life to getting targets for 99% of their guild. Or you join Class-R and see a raid target once every 2-3 months. Is there really no solution to make the game more enjoyable for the majority of the population? Playing EQ is great, but not like this.

Nobody is forcing you to play here. The exclusivity of raid targets being monopolized by top guilds is absolutely classic.

Do you have a solution in mind that preserves the classic nature of the server and increases the "fun" for everyone?

By the way, the shot you took at the GMs (and you called two out by name) is total bull shit...just sharing my thoughts. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] GMs work (and it is WORK) to make this totally FREE game stay afloat. Anything less than thanks for making p99 real or constructive criticism to make it better is worthless.

Check out the "shit show" that other classic servers offer...p99 is light years ahead of any other place to play classic EQ. Bottom line: if you want to experience classic EQ the best place ANYWHERE to do it is right here...most of us are more than willing to put up with the problems still being worked out if it means getting to play classic style EQ.

[Doil_Boil]

Originally Posted by fastboy21 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Nobody is forcing you to play here. The exclusivity of raid targets being monopolized by top guilds is absolutely classic.

Do you have a solution in mind that preserves the classic nature of the server and increases the "fun" for everyone?

By the way, the shot you took at the GMs (and you called two out by name) is total bull shit...just sharing my thoughts. [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] GMs work (and it is WORK) to make this totally FREE game stay afloat. Anything less than thanks for making p99 real or constructive criticism to make it better is worthless.

Check out the "shit show" that other classic servers offer...p99 is light years ahead of any other place to play classic EQ. Bottom line: if you want to experience classic EQ the best place ANYWHERE to do it is right here...most of us are more than willing to put up with the problems still being worked out if it means getting to play classic style EQ.

Actually, some servers had raid calendars. So, there's a solution that's totally classic.

[fastboy21]

Originally Posted by Doil_Boil [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Actually, some servers had raid calendars. So, there's a solution that's totally classic.

It was player driven on these servers.

[Crawdad]

Originally Posted by Doil_Boil [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Actually, some servers had raid calendars. So, there's a solution that's totally classic.

Raid calendars seldom reflected "Current Content" though. Sure, you can have a Nagafen, Vox, PoSky, etc... raid calendar system, but its not going to be until the top 2 (maybe 3) guilds have picked it clean and don't need them anymore. I don't believe for a second that on Live every server's Top Guild didn't hold on desperately to claim VP/NToV/VT/Premier Loot Pinata-zone for themselves, so why expect differently here?

It seems awful because, as obvious as it is... We're on year 5 of Kunark, when it lasted 8 Months on Live. Soon(tm).

[Tormax]

Originally Posted by Doil_Boil [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Actually, some servers had raid calendars. So, there's a solution that's totally classic.

This is exactly how it was on Saryrn.

Request your guild to be put into the ToV rotation. If you appear to have the levels/toons to attempt it you are given a date to try. If you were unable to clear it then you were taken off the rotation for X amount of months before you could attempt it again. Clear it and you get a spot in rotation.

Too many guilds? Then split up the spawns by difficulty.

Welcome to the Halls of Testing [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[central scrutinizer]

Originally Posted by fastboy21 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Nobody is forcing you to play here. The exclusivity of raid targets being monopolized by top guilds is absolutely classic.

Not through massive reserves of additional accounts to camp out at targets all over norrath it isn't.

Raiding on p99 has not resembled classic for a long time.