Quote:
Originally Posted by Baler
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
I really hope we get to find out tonight and not a week later who won...
Did you know most people think the American civil war as over slavery?
It wasn't. it was over individual state rights and the fed wanting control.
|
I can agree to disagree on this one, I really think it depends on where you school and grew up for our generation. And I dont hold anything against anyone who agrees or disagrees with this.
I
would agree a percentile of people fought and died in the civil war for individual state rights. But was it the cause and reason for the civil war? I dont think you can prove that. While I think it is possible to prove otherwise
because there is written declaration from states that started the civil war that it was specifically about slavery. yes it was their state _right_ to have slavery, but that was the _only_ right they were fighting for. So it's actually misleading to say that it was "over state rights"... it was over slavery, but the right for a state to have its own slavery law.
Not for annoying northerner taxes or federal abortion law. It was because the country was going non slavery and these states did not want that to be the way. And so they wanted their "right" to slavery.
So its fair to say sure that some wanted maybe state rights (I'd wager those people didn't have a very high opinion of the mental capacity of free'd slaves and were balking at the idea of it, but that is totally anecdotal) but as for the cause of the civil war being over state rights, states wanted their right to
slavery and nothing in the constitution would protect that, so they succeeded.
Ergo, it was over slavery. But, if you want to champion those few men that fought and died for liberty, under the direction of slave owners, go for it! But, I will agree to disagree
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.] Id change my mind if someone could convince me!