The official permission to post your opinion thread

[Bagzan]

I'll give you a break since I know you have a hard time typing as well as probably reading and understanding English, Raren. Notice how I said:

You can't really set up a rotation and then say "oh but it's only for these 2 guilds, sorry everybody else."

That would imply that yes, the rotation was only between 2 guilds.

If you have a rotation that is only between 2 guilds it doesn't work on a server where 6+ guilds have aspirations of raiding the same content. Either you don't let them in and eventually they kill mobs that are in the rotation between the 2 guilds that have an agreement, causing an issue between those 2, or you do let them in, say via killing a gateway mob (not really any of those in classic ala Aary in NToV) which inevitably leads to the whole "too many cooks in the kitchen" dilemma of having 6+ guilds on a rotation for 6 mobs meaning a guild it basically getting about a boss a week which nobody is going to be happy with, especially the original 2 guilds.