Ginelin's BP Dilemma - Vote please

[Farzo]

Hi, Server

tl;dr

Ginelin gave stuff away, wants it back.

Want's his Ikky BP back!

Poll to what I should do:

http://strawpoll.me/1864722

Please read vote rules in post below!
Poll closes in 1 weeks time.

Long story:

I was in MM hanging near the entrance kicking stones with my level 20 somthing Paladin waiting for a group spot approximately a week ago when Ginelin zoned in and come up to me and asked if I was new, I said "yes, about 3 weeks new" ( which is the truth, just came back from 2 years away from blue and started on Red ).

I had saved up all the bronze I found while levelling my Enchanter and saved up 500pp and bought a spiffy Mithril 2hs -- twinked I thought! Not he thought, he than handed me a bunch of items saying he was quitting. Did some /oocing telling people that he had given me x items and called for more people to come get the rest of his items.

I thought wow what a nice guy! I am now set to level on! I thought what a great way to quit a game, and asked him why he was quiting: he gave his reasons.


Approximately 4-5 days later he logs on to his other toon and starts giving items out to other people, but here is where it gets a bit murky, 10-15 hours later he logs on and starts to pm me asking for one of the items back ( Ikky bp )! also been just the most expensive item he gave me and not the rest.

I told him, how do I know it's the real Ginelin and not his friend who is logging in to try and /reclaim some items for his own gains - I asked him a few questions about the events and he responded to them correctly to as they had played out. I also asked him why the change? so quick? he said he wanted to come back and play with friends

My response was to say let me think about it; he has since promptly with in 10-15mins of me logging in sent me tells asking what the go is.


Should a kind deem be repaid with a kind deed back? or should this be taken as an Indian giver? or a smart friend who has been given Ginelin's account taking an opportunity to gain more then just an account.

Please vote above.

Poll closes in 1 weeks time.