Casual ranger - velious weaponry?

[Cecily]

Dmg bonus gives it an edge over better ratios. It's not a bad ratio weapon either. Earthcaller is 14/24 primary only. The proc is only 3 dps and you really shouldn't factor in proc damage when evaluating weapons. The ratios and delays give you an idea of how it'll perform all the time. And you absolutely should not factor weapon stats into weapon evaluation either. Having an idea what hand a weapon goes into helps as well. Click my spread sheet earlier in the thread for proof.

Offhands you want pure ratio. The only thing that matters in determining one weapon over another.
Primaries are a little more difficult, because you have to factor in dmg bonus at higher levels. You want a mix of high ratio and low delay.

And you also have to be aware of your situation. If you're fighting a bunch of mobs at once and an enchanter is mezzing around you, the Fayguard is the best possible weapon to kill that enchanter. Razor Fang works in any situation, so it's probably the best overall. Not the highest DPS though.