List System Proposed Changes

[cd288]

Originally Posted by YendorLootmonkey [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

There’s a slight difference in bringing 60 guildies to camp manastone on a list that moves in linear order and bringing 60 guildies to make sure the odds are in your favor when a manastone drops if everyone in the list could potentially win it.

Personally, I think after X minutes of spawning, the mob should auto-aggro the #1 person every server tick regardless if FD, invis, or hidden. If you doubt your ability to solo the mob, come back when you're level 50.

Agreed. Making it randomly given to someone on the list regardless of position will just make it ripe for guild abuse. If the list is 200 people long, for example, and it includes 100+ players from some guild who has just packed their members onto the list, you are essentially moving yourself back towards the scenario the list was designed to prevent (i.e. a guild trying to ensure Manastones only go to its members).

Sure, it wouldn't be 100% guaranteed to go to members of that guild, but just packing your members onto the list ensures high odds that someone from your guild will be getting the drop.