Is this ok to do?

[Beatitudes]

Group of 6 chilling together clearing out names. 5 of the 6 are in the same guild and the 6th is an independent contractor. Few hours pass and all loot is rolled on. Big name pops and 2 items drop. One item worth 3k the other is a 10k to 15k druid spell. We roll on the 3k item. About 5 mins pass and the toon, not in the guild, asks if we are going to roll on the spell. No one in the group is a druid. But 2 have a level 60 druid. The non-guild toon is told that it was given to the person in the guild because they do a lot for the guild. The only loot rule set up was we roll on all and need before greed, for the classes in the group. Is this the way?