Shadows of Luclin Your opinion?

[Kevlar]

Luclin was dumb because it took away too much from the tolkein-esque fantasy world that EQ was built on.

Planes of power brought the game back a little bit because it focused more on something you would expect out of a mature game setting, something that had been done in Advanced Dungeons and Dragons years earlier, Ultra high level Players challenging their deities.

POP books ruined the feel for the size of the world a lot more than the luclin spires did, but cats on the moon was just a ridiculous concept that really f%6ked up the fantasy setting. Something I would expect out of a Japanime game geared to 12 year olds, not something that was trying to pass itself off as a heroic D&D style game.