Best Overall Melee???

[Uberom]

Thanks to everyone for their input. I realize my question was very vague but I intended it that way so you could elaborate however you choose. It worked because I got the type of answers I was looking for.

I was told long prior to Kunark that SHD and PAL get OP in this expansion, but this seems to not be the case.

Also realize I chose to omit the BRD class because , well, I'm just not interested! I also have no desire to play a MNK.

So I guess my choices are :

Great DPS/Utility: ROG
Good DPS/Tank: WAR

Is it accurate to say that a fully geared ROG with epic will beat out a fully geared WAR with epic in DPS?