Is it that hard to have a raid solution? Here - E . Z .

[President]

+/- 24 hours on on raid mob spawns.

Naggy/Vox - First guild with 15 people in the zone get first attempt, within a reasonable 1 hour window. Then rotate. If there is a dispute or "close call" on who was there first. Raid leaders /rand for first attempt. (1 hour window still applies to whoever /rand, then rotate)

Cazic/Inno - Whatever guild is already clearing trash gets first attempt. If two guilds are in clearing trash at spawn time, raid leader from each guild /rand for first attempt.

Good faith should be shown to each or all guilds and plenty of time for their "attempt" regardless of how "fast" you think they should be moving.