ASOIAF / Game of Thrones (SPOILERS INSIDE)

[AzzarTheGod]

Originally Posted by Sirken [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

ive heard this before, its just hard for me to subscribe to. Tyrion has two different color'd eyes, neither are purple like Targs. Tyrion doesnt have the platinum hair either. also, i think Tywin would have killed Tyrion if he thought it was the mad kings bastard rape baby. i just can't see Tywin swallowing his family pride to raise Tyrion as his own.

that said, its very possible. i dont remember the exact details, but i know the timelines match up for the mad king and johanna being in the same place.

Yeah...only way that subplot for Tyrion would make sense (under the watchful eye of Tywin) would be if someone, a midwife/nanny dyed his hair his entire life from birth, and the readers were given the explanation that the genes just weren't strong with him because he was a dwarf.

But then Tyrion would have full knowledge/suspicion that he was a bastard, but could have possibly lived the lie that maybe "the genes just weren't strong with him". IDK. The Tyrion character already deems himself a bastard of sorts, I doubt the above scenario would have changed his chapters in the books very much at all and could have worked.

Just bullshitting about what it would take to make the tinfoil Tyrion bastard plot believable in GRRM's world. Tywin is just too controlling and slick to have a bastard in his midst and grant it titles.