Monk epic brother balatin MQ fail?

[Sirquestalot]

First question that comes to mind: did the enchanter and the other person actually turn in the correct pipes? Perhaps they had both or even something that used the same inventory graphic, but didn't make certain they were turning in the right item. Since I have had these kind of issues in the past myself, we have to ask if for example, 2 karnor's pipes got turned in.