Quest Issue: Cabilis Monk Penance

[GretchenRPH]

yeah I have done this twice. The first time because I was a dumb newly-newb after years and when she asked me if I had my shackle, I traded it to her. Boom, now I am without it, so I did the Penance, and got it back.

Once I had the shackle of stone (from turning in shackles of dust and clay) I would no longer have a LORE issue, so like a lot of monks I was going to have 2 shackle quests moving behind each other. I went back and did Penance over again, but this time, Niska didn't give me anything for the book and completed penance bag.

So I don't get it...sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't.

I did it twice back when Kunark was brand new in the 1999 era on Live and doing this was not uncommon for Iksar monks.

EDIT oh wait, I don't think the second time I handed the book to the Toilmaster, I just asked for the hammer and bag. That might be why.