Continued from Trakanon thread

[Nirgon]

Supreme went around saying he had me on ignore, yet..

Anyways I had people jumping down my shit saying I'd know something if I logged in within the last 5 months. Well maybe I haven't but it doesn't look like I'm wrong.

Broken is requiring people to wear so much magic gear to resist a spell that is classically a very high resist rate spell, especially one that results in such a resounding splat when landed in group PvP. Stuns too.

Everyone here wants classic EQ but they have no problem at all with things that make playing their classes easier or trivializing content. Big shock, right. What happened to wanting a real classic server? Or a challenge?

[Nizzarr]

I also was chain stunned 4 or 5 times by that same bat with around 100 mr, during that same fight

[Nirgon]

Samwise as far as play better...

I think in that posted scenario you would have been in for a real shock if charm worked like it did on live, and root/stun weren't in their current state.

Not saying you're bad, because I don't think you are, but I can see a reason to make your defense and unfortunately it is very self serving.

[Nirgon]

Originally Posted by Nizzarr [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I also was chain stunned 4 or 5 times by that same bat with around 100 mr, during that same fight

I agree with this guy on the point he makes because he's right.

I don't care for him personally or his history here. But he obviously wants a more classic experience and he's not wrong in the statements he's made here.

A charmed bat shouldn't stun lock someone, nor should the basilisks in saw in Lguk.

I don't think the changes required are going to require entire reworkings of systems or any real massive effort. It's 3 lines of spells as they effect players. Stuns (esp if whirl hasn't been killed with fire yet), roots (esp mage earth pet roots) and blinds.

There have been enough PvP servers with broken mechanics and less than 100 population, why does this one having a slower xp rate make it special?

[SamwiseBanned]

lol Nirgons who argument comes from one first cast root if its even that i mean, we are looking at a splice of a log. ive posted tests, mindsculptor has posted tests, Null has posted tests with 1000s of roots. this is all the evidence you need to pursue you differently?

[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

[SamwiseBanned]

Originally Posted by Nirgon [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I agree with this guy on the point he makes because he's right.

I don't care for him personally or his history here. But he obviously wants a more classic experience and he's not wrong in the statements he's made here.

A charmed bat shouldn't stun lock someone, nor should the basilisks in saw in Lguk.

I don't think the changes required are going to require entire reworkings of systems or any real massive effort. It's 3 lines of spells as they effect players. Stuns (esp if whirl hasn't been killed with fire yet), roots (esp mage earth pet roots) and blinds.

There have been enough PvP servers with broken mechanics and less than 100 population, why does this one having a slower xp rate make it special?

so upon charming, the mob should magically become weaker and lose its abilities?

[Nirgon]

You posting that picture is awfully ironic given that you are saying things are fine in the face of that evidence and Nizzar being chain stunned with 100 MR. Way to face plant on that one.

[SamwiseBanned]

Originally Posted by Nizzarr [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I also was chain stunned 4 or 5 times by that same bat with around 100 mr, during that same fight

which could have been avoided had 1 of the 14 Nihilum rushing the bat PL group dispelled the bat lol.

[SamwiseBanned]

Originally Posted by Nirgon [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

You posting that picture is awfully ironic given that you are saying things are fine in the face of that evidence and Nizzar being chain stunned with 100 MR. Way to face plant on that one.

those bats stun me at a 100 mr, and i assure you he wasnt "chain stunned"

[Nirgon]

Originally Posted by SamwiseBanned [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

so upon charming, the mob should magically become weaker and lose its abilities?

You continue to plummet in my eyes as someone who knows classic pvp mechanics so quickly you're going to need an atmospheric heat shield.