FE Raid Scene Proposal

[doraf]

Originally Posted by doraf [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

all you motherfuckers got an extra chromosome or something? This shit ain't hard to understand.

^^ Me, Real Doraf.

Sloan is much nicer than I am.

[Tanthallas]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

If those tier 1 mobs are rotated among everyone and not just tier 1 guilds then fine. the post leaves a lot to be misinterpreted to that part.

While that doesn't still mean im on board with it, if that's the case I retract my statement and apologize for my misunderstanding and "extra chromosome"...

The tiers are open for guilds to come and go catherin, and the requirements of entering any which tier are not being set up such that tier 1 guilds are able to completely cock block tier 2 guilds from joining t1 - we want to set it up in a way that allows for some mobility such that if t2 guilds try, they can move to tier one without even the ability of tier one guilds to hinder that. Now if T2 guilds hinder eachother, well, thats a different story - but noone is worried about that, people are worried about the big bad t1 poopsockers.

[Hitpoint]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

If those tier 1 mobs are rotated among everyone and not just tier 1 guilds then fine. the post leaves a lot to be misinterpreted to that part.

While that doesn't still mean im on board with it, if that's the case I retract my statement and apologize for my misunderstanding and "extra chromosome"...

no need to be insulting about it

If you can kill two of these, during the FFA portions of two months, then you can be tier 1 and you can rotate on the first four.

o Trak
o VS
o CT
o Inny
o Talendor
o Gorenaire
o Seversomething

[-Catherin-]

Originally Posted by Hitpoint [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

If you can kill two of these, during the FFA portions of two months, then you can be tier 1 and you can rotate on the first four.

wait, so you do have to be tier 1 and be subject to tier 1 style raiding to be on your rotation for trak, VS, Inny, and CT? if that is the case then I did not misunderstand.

the point is that the tier 2 guilds don't WANT to be tier 1 guilds, and do not want to be subject to tier 1 guild raidstyle. It is not enjoyable to us and we simply cant do it anyways. that's what eventually lead to all of this in the first place

[Funkutron5000]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

wait, so you do have to be tier 1 and be subject to tier 1 style raiding to be on your rotation for trak, VS, Inny, and CT? if that is the case then I did not misunderstand.

the point is that the tier 2 guilds don't WANT to be tier 1 guilds, and do not want to be subject to tier 1 guild raidstyle. that's what eventually lead to all of this in the first place

Originally Posted by Tanthallas [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

The tiers are open for guilds to come and go catherin, and the requirements of entering any which tier are not being set up such that tier 1 guilds are able to completely cock block tier 2 guilds from joining t1 - we want to set it up in a way that allows for some mobility such that if t2 guilds try, they can move to tier one without even the ability of tier one guilds to hinder that. Now if T2 guilds hinder eachother, well, thats a different story - but noone is worried about that, people are worried about the big bad t1 poopsockers.

[Tanthallas]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

wait, so you do have to be tier 1 and be subject to tier 1 style raiding to be on your rotation for trak, VS, Inny, and CT? if that is the case then I did not misunderstand.

the point is that the tier 2 guilds don't WANT to be tier 1 guilds, and do not want to be subject to tier 1 guild raidstyle. It is not enjoyable to us and we simply cant do it anyways. that's what eventually lead to all of this in the first place

No catherin, you will be in a tier 1 rotation for the first two weeks of the month, just the same as the tier 2 rotation that would exist for the first 2 weeks of the month. You will not be subject to any raiding style you do not want, unless you are saying you do not want rotations.

From there on, you can maintain your position as t1 or move down to t2 depending on your actions in the FFA periods. It will be harder for a t1 guild to maintain its position in t1 than it will be for a t2 guild to enter t1 because we are saying that we can modify this to add that t1 guilds will not be eligible to kill a few FFA mobs during the FFA period. This means that t2 progression to t1 will not be blocked by anyone but t2 guilds themselves; seeing as FE / IB / TMO are the only ones that t2 guilds are worried about, or so they say, then their progression to t1 rotations is completely independent of these guilds blocking them.

And I would add that it is not necessarily going to be beneficial to always be on T1 rotation. Not only is there the potential for mobility here, but there will be mobility - especially if one Tier gets crowded.

[doraf]

Originally Posted by -Catherin- [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

wait, so you do have to be tier 1 and be subject to tier 1 style raiding to be on your rotation for trak, VS, Inny, and CT? if that is the case then I did not misunderstand.

the point is that the tier 2 guilds don't WANT to be tier 1 guilds, and do not want to be subject to tier 1 guild raidstyle. It is not enjoyable to us and we simply cant do it anyways. that's what eventually lead to all of this in the first place

Then go play Guildwars2 or Rift, not Classic Everquest. There is a reason it's call everquest. Because it might take forever for some of you to get an epic. You think McQuaid and gang were sitting around VI headquarters flipping a coin between Everquest or Welfarequest as the name?

[Alarti0001]

Originally Posted by doraf [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Then go play Guildwars2 or Rift, not Classic Everquest. There is a reason it's call everquest. Because it might take forever for some of you to get an epic. You think McQuaid and gang were sitting around VI headquarters flipping a coin between Everquest or Welfarequest as the name?

They could also play Post POP everquest!

[Tanthallas]

Disclaimer, Doraf is now Doraf lol

[Kope]

Originally Posted by doraf [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

You think McQuaid and gang were sitting around VI headquarters flipping a coin between Everquest or Welfarequest as the name?

Oh, then let's not go with the rotation situation, let's go with the staff submitted proposal where you guys can play all the competitionquest you want and we can do our thing [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.].