Project 1999

Go Back   Project 1999 > Green Community > Green Server Chat

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 03-30-2021, 01:09 PM
kipoki kipoki is offline
Large Rat


Join Date: Dec 2019
Posts: 5
Default Melee Worthlessness - The Biggest Balance Problem There Is

I was going to post this as a reply to the "is enchanter OP?" poll thread, only to realize it's been locked, but I think it's such an important topic necessary for some level of discussion (or proper reasonings to put me in my place about it) that I need to make a thread bout it.

First and foremost, before anything else, I *DON'T* think enchanters or any other class are OP -- I think the 'power-classes' like ENC and MAG, and to some degree every spellcaster, solo or in group, are just toeing the line of "the proper balance" to make it through a game as gruelingly difficult as classic EQ. You still need some level of smarts, some level of knowledge, some level of hard-won experience in the game, guide-studying, figuring out how things work, time commitment, perseverance and stubbornness to get far in this game -- outside of powerleveling, of course, but given not only how unforgiving the game is in a general sense, and aspects like spell resists, the extreme state of small mana pools and slow mana recovery, the competitiveness of every popular exp/money spot and just how fast you die when things inevitably go wrong and how punishing death is, I couldn't call any class in this game 'overpowered' so much as, at best, in case of ENC perhaps most of all, "just right, able to cheese the game back almost as hard as it cheeses its players".

The problem arises when you factor in classes that DON'T have all those tools to compete with the insane "overtuning" of the enemies (though that's how we like it, what makes the game more satisfying than newer MMOs and generally makes grouping at all stages far more popular than it would be in others). Even IN groups, where they're seemingly more "needed" and where they flock since soloing gets exponentially harder to even try to do rapidly the higher level you get... The melees. They were designed to fill the same void they do in every other classical RPG or RPG-inspired game, the big dudes that take hits so the finger-wagglers can safely do their waggling, or to do consistent, constant DPS while the mages are meditating or against mobs that resist magic or what-have-you. This would have been fine if the only spellcasters in the game had been clerics and wizards, maybe, but well...

Let me give you a story of my recent personal experience. I finally came to green late as Kunark launched, I made an IKS WAR (I know they can't wear plate till velious and are thus frowned upon but I also know I was future-proofing a bit and I love the racials and aesthetics). I painstakingly got the guy up into the 30s after weeks of hardcore play and had EXCELLENT equipment every step of the way thanks to kind strangers, friends and guildmates, and my own blood sweat and tears scrabbling every single copper I could every step of the way to fill out every slot with at least decent mid-tier stuff as soon as possible.. People appreciated me in groups and I think I did a decent job with everythign I could. But despite all this hard work and commitment, despite the hundreds, thousands of plat that went into gearing me up to fairly twinkish levels, consistently every single time I partied with any kind of pet class, even several levels below me, the pet was consistently MONUMENTALLY out-DPSing me, even with no weapons, and I'm pretty damn sure they'd out-tank me if people bothered to throw a set of cheap noob gear on them and keep them healed. No matter what I did, what I tried, how I tried to squeeze every iota of stats and ability and goodness out of my character, or how much money I funneled into it, I couldn't even begin to dream to even halfway catch up to this naked pet in sheer raw power for my level, they're scaled just the same as NPCs which is to say 'white mob should be enough of a threat to need multiple players to take it down after like level 5, unless you cheese the game as is often necessary". Though my guy was so kitted out I was able to solo high blues and sometimes even whites all the way up to level 30 mobs -- then the stat skyrocket is so blatant and insane no melee can even dream of it anymore, while of course every single spellcaster can with some tactics and patience. Or just throwing junk at it till it dies if you're a MAG I guess lol. I even tried my best to get into all aspects of crafting and any side-ability I could use to give me any edge, and let me tell you, all crafting is completely useless in this era lmao, best to use that time to farm some cash for a set of banded and some HMBP's and just get fletching to the not-at-all-high level you need to craft the longest range arrows for pulling, which is all that matters, you'll never get any damage out of them and any amount of 'hard work' and 'squeezing every last drop out of the class' is pointless and adds absolutely nothing.

The point I'm trying to make is -- why the hell would you ever roll a melee or bring a melee to any group, ever, when bringing a magic user or ESPECIALLY pet class is just infinitely, gargantuanly, objectively, far far better? You need literally zero gear whatsoever to humongously outperform even geared-to-the-teeth melees. Just summon a pet and send it in. You can give it almost any gear you want and it will immediately auto-equip it. Sure, it makes it a pain to give it expensive stuff that you know will disappear forever as soon as it dies or you log or zone, but... so? What are you gonna do, go all the way to EC and spend a month trying to peddle it off, or worse yet, give it to a melee noob when you'll get infinitely more use out of it letting your pet have it and getting you and/or your group that much more easy and fast exp and money? Why buff any of the melees when you could buff the pets and see so much more effect for it? Why give even good weapons to the melees instead of the pets? Why heal the melees when you could heal the pets? Why in the world would you make any melee class instead of bringing a class that literally can effortlessly summon or charm a mob that IS, immediately, with no money or gear, not only as good as, but BETTER THAN any melee you could possibly add to your group, PLUS all the myriad spells and abilities that you get as a spell-user? And no matter what spellcaster you are you're going to get unfathomably uber-useful core abilities too like bind and gate, at least some menial CC like root, and likely things like food/drink summoning or other means to not bother with some core aspects of the game. Still, I don't think this is 'op' -- I just think melee is severely, severely UP.

I know there are some apparent exceptions but, well -- let's go over a few.
- Warriors get disciplines later that let them tank raid bosses. They're the only class that can tank raid bosses.
-- Great! That's exactly one solitary warrior needed per entire raid, and 99.999% of the playerbase will never touch any raid ever. You all know that this warrior will be some ogre war a guildie with a DRU or NEC main will make as an alt real quick and get powerlevelled and omega-twinked just to fulfill this one purpose, anyway.
- Rogues get backstab, that's pretty strong, right?
-- Yes, but not so much stronger than other pet DPS or spell DPS that it really matters, and in some zones there are rogue NPCs to charm that do this anyway, so what's the point?
- Rogues can also sneak/invis and scout or do sick corpse runs!
-- Yeah, but who needs scouting anymore when we all have fully detailed maps of every zone in the game, and/or use gnome ghetto tracking, and we can just kill all the mobs anyway with CC and pet barrages? And who needs corpse runs when you could just summon them, pull through floor, use a bard or other class that can do it just as well etc?
- Monks do so much great DPS and can pull and FD and it's neat!
-- Yea, but pets are still gonna outdps them before raid-tier endgame and again, who needs a puller when you could just kill/CC everything with enough pets/spellcasters? And necros can FD for when that's needed.
- Hybrids can do some stuff, maybe, sometimes, and hold hate well.
-- No one on the planet's gonna party with a hybrid as long as exp penalty is in place, the most ludicrously pointless aspect of 'keep it classic' that serves literally zero purpose whatsoever except make already-grotesquely-underpowered classes even less viable to play or wanted by anyone. and even after that, literally why bother when you could just send in more pets and root the mob so they tank it? And do many many times over the DPS of these classes that do far less dmg than warriors, and warriors do far less than pets?

So yeah like... I'm not saying anything should be nerfed, just that melees should be buffed to actually compete with pets and even-leveled mobs, or be able to conceivably have any reason to exist alongside spellcasters when there's absolutely no way for them to ever even dream of approaching the DPS of most of them, especially pet ones, tanking is pointless when pets and charmed mobs exist atm, and they have absolutely utterly nothing they can do of any real value at all compared to ANY spellcaster class, and have much much much harder time doing the basic stuff of the game for not only no reward but *less* powerful or needed of a character objectively, *and* they take a million times more money to make even somewhat viable, but SITLL far LESS viable than a naked spellcaster of any type...

I know this won't be changed ever and the purpose of this server is to simulate classic EQ as closely as possible, imbalances and all, but it really gets under my skin and pisses me off so I wanted to make a post about it :P

TL;DR all melees (except bards which don't count) suck and are terrible and worthless, prove me wrong
  #2  
Old 03-30-2021, 01:17 PM
madgarin madgarin is offline
Kobold


Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 159
Default

Make a friend.
  #3  
Old 03-30-2021, 01:35 PM
Gustoo Gustoo is offline
Planar Protector

Gustoo's Avatar

Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: The side of Bristlebane
Posts: 6,039
Default

A melee is a pet that you can control directly.

Best group is 5 mages and 1 enchanter.

But who cares.
__________________
Discord PVP Server:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rogean View Post
Lost but not forgotten.
  #4  
Old 03-30-2021, 02:04 PM
Toxigen Toxigen is offline
Planar Protector

Toxigen's Avatar

Join Date: Jan 2021
Posts: 4,724
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kipoki [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

TL;DR all melees (except bards which don't count) suck and are terrible and worthless, prove me wrong
No need to prove it, you're just wrong.
__________________
ENC | MNK | WAR | ROG | CLR | DRU | SHM | NEC | PAL | BRD
  #5  
Old 03-30-2021, 02:15 PM
rewinder47 rewinder47 is offline
Orc


Join Date: Oct 2019
Posts: 30
Default

"No one on the planet is going to party with hybrids"

Not only is this untrue, but you're a dick if you think this way. Plenty of people play as, and group with, hybrids because the game is about having fun and playing what you like.

Your whole post is basically whining and complaining that you can't play as a melee because it's not perfect statistical min/maxing. I wonder if you even get any enjoyment out of the game when you worry so much about perfect effectiveness. Maybe you should play something else
  #6  
Old 03-30-2021, 02:59 PM
Snortles Chortles Snortles Chortles is offline
Banned


Join Date: May 2020
Location: BRoOKlyN
Posts: 1,075
Default

if i ever saw a tank LFG i would take one
good thing i can charm
(LOL)
  #7  
Old 03-30-2021, 03:07 PM
Videri Videri is offline
Planar Protector

Videri's Avatar

Join Date: Dec 2014
Posts: 2,837
Default

OP, tanks are not for doing damage. They are for taking hits, and hopefully pulling.

Player tanks are valuable. Those all-powerful casters want someone to go pull so they don't have to stand up. Just make sure to have a bow and some arrows and fletching materials.

Pets are not always a sufficient replacement for tank players. Players can pull intelligently; for example, try to get singles, warn of multiple mobs incoming, die away from camp instead of training the pet master.

There is a tank shortage right now in the 50+ range. When I log in my useless potato warrior, I instantly get a group. Is it the same at lower levels?

Furthermore, in my opinion, warriors are a guild class. You need a guild because a guild needs you. A guild with any sense will support and enable their warriors.
  #8  
Old 03-30-2021, 03:14 PM
A Knight A Knight is offline
Fire Giant


Join Date: Jan 2020
Posts: 653
Default

I hate to sound like a broken record.

If everything is fair and balanced then you take away from the feel of a real world. Then everything is bland and equal. Everything would feel like Wow where it may look like a world but it doesn't feel it.

As long as everything is relatively equal at high level. Plus or minus some concerns like rangers. I'm also from pvp though so hybrids have a job.
  #9  
Old 03-30-2021, 03:18 PM
Gustoo Gustoo is offline
Planar Protector

Gustoo's Avatar

Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: The side of Bristlebane
Posts: 6,039
Default

Yeah just turn on red and see what class you want to be when you're pegged at max level and gear.

There are tradeoffs thats why the game is actually fun.
__________________
Discord PVP Server:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Rogean View Post
Lost but not forgotten.
  #10  
Old 03-30-2021, 03:28 PM
Jibartik Jibartik is offline
Planar Protector


Join Date: May 2015
Posts: 22,216
Default

I hate to say that I think wow fixed melee by taking disciplines and expanding them to basically be "melee spell lines" and using stamina instead of mana to cast them.
Closed Thread

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:50 PM.


Everquest is a registered trademark of Daybreak Game Company LLC.
Project 1999 is not associated or affiliated in any way with Daybreak Game Company LLC.
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.