shaman hp vs mp

[daxchunjae1912]

If this has been beaten down to death x amount of times I apologize but if you had a high level shaman lets say 57-59 range and had these set hitpoints and manapoints:

1st scenario:
HP: 2300
MP: 2800

or

2nd scenario:
HP:2800
MP:2300

Which one would you choose and why? I've been asking this for months and can't get a straight answer. Some say the 2nd since you have more to cannibalize, some say 1st because more mana means you can get off more spells, some say neither as long as you're dancing, and some say screw it get to 60 and torpor and it's a wash?