What is the hardest dungeon in the game?

[Vexenu]

Factor in the requirement of using level-appropriate gear.

Some of the lower-mid level dungeons are absolute deathtraps, which is why no one uses them. Examples:

Splitpaw Lair
Dalnir
Runnyeye
Droga
Cazic Thule

I would argue that these are actually some of the most challenging dungeons in the game when adjusted for level and gear. I still remember a particularly amazing/disastrous group I once had in Runnyeye that culminated in a fight to the death with a huge train of goblins, in which four group members were slain and two barely survived. Probably the most intense and memorable battle I've had in EQ. And in Runnyeye, of all places.

Anyway, the question stands: what do you think is the hardest dungeon in the game when adjusting for level and gear?

[mcoy]

I'd argue CT here - the agro through walls kills most classic camps.

[Jimjam]

Qeynos Sewers, if for no other reason than the smell. Fairly good loot though if you remember to bring your clothes peg.

[Twochain]

Tower of Frozen Shadow floor 2

It's not even close.

[Maner]

Sirens grotto is pretty stupid since we have the balls out version and not the nerfed one.

[mcoy]

Originally Posted by mcoy [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I'd argue CT here - the agro through walls kills most classic camps.

I meant the healing through walls, but I'm sure most understood.

[Evia]

There has only been one dungeon that I've wiped in more times than I had a successful run. That's the crypt of dalnir so that has my vote.

[branamil]

Originally Posted by Maner [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Sirens grotto is pretty stupid since we have the balls out version and not the nerfed one.

My vote for hardest dungeon adjusted for level even.

I bet some of the areas have never been cleared since it's been available.

The main temple area is ludicrous.. a dozen mobs within aggro range of eachother, unmezzable... with two icy servants that proc a 500 damage dispel AoE..

[mickmoranis]

This is tough to answer because of the opinion factor, but..

I think solB, level and gear apropriate is far more difficult than anything listed, the HPs are a jump up from Mistmoore, see invis everywhere is HUGELY DIFFICULT for new players that havent been playing this game for so long, and well, yeah, pull 1 mob at the king wrong and you're fighting 30

cazic thule is challanging cus youre fighting greens one minuet then reds the next, but its really not that difficult... altho in classic I never really knew anyone that could figure out how to camp shit in that orb room so maybe ur right?

[skarlorn]

Kaesora should be on that list.

Runny eye is a lot less dangerous since the revamp. Way fewer crazy pathing mobs and see invisible shamans.