WTF is going on.

[Maximus]

Does it seem like favoritism is going on here? same question that's been asked for ages and i ask you to be the judge.
On sunday morning, in the name of the lord, Transcendence, Divinity, and Inglourious Basterds meet up for our usual sunday mass, a nice shootout in Plane of Hate for the named spawned mob that was up, Maestro of Rankor.
FACT:
Transcendence had the first 15 in zone.
Transcendence was not notified by any secondary guild of 30 minute timers, and infact, called our 30 minutes IN SHOUT in order to inform other guilds present of our intentions.
Transcendence was the first to move into the cubby to pull maestro area ( there really isnt a designated pull area for maestro, so this really is not an advantage to any guild, wherever they may be.)
Transcendence was the first to Engage Maestro.
Divinity and IB jumped in since they believed they should have first shot, or whatever god given rights IB believes they have, over any boss.
Inglourious Basterds stole the kill, and they were not even in question of being the first runner up to kill the mob.

Maestro dropped his shittiest loot ever, 2 monk masks (6ac effect ultravision). in which my guildmate Taluvill, out of our anger for getting screwed here, looted and deleted, as we felt it was our mob, by the book, constituting it our kill, and our loot, whether IB kill stole it or not.
The_Nameless neglected to gather any information from our side of the story, and infact heeded what he called, Majority of complaints that were being sent in by Inglourious Basterds and Divinity.
and so i ask, is this how GMs are gonna handle events in game? the more that cries the more that gets?
And while we have screenshots and logs of all of our information, this seems to be neglected and put aside to abide to the people who cry the most.
Taluvill was given a warning, by The_Nameless that morning, which i can agree with, deleting items out of spite is a bit of a rash move.
Taluvill got banned for 14 days for deleting two of the shittiest monk masks that maestro drops (considered his delete drops) that evening, for no consisten punishement rule that i can see here.
The Fact that Dblock deleted our cleric arms,(X10 better than both of those masks combined) and only got a couple of days worth of ban seems irrational to me by these statements.
Infact someone being banned for using macroquest for 7 days seems like a reasonably weak punishment compared to this sudden move on Taluvill.
and i ask you, why isnt the guild who got to go to Plane of Sky, keep some of the uberest loot, and run around with it, not get a single slap on the wrist? WTF IS GOING ON?