Thoughts on movement from Class C to Class R

[Phats]

Originally Posted by arsenalpow [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

no class c kills for 1 month, inside and outside VP
simple enough, no bullshit popularity votes, no potential bias

This may be simple but can be abused. If I was a Class R guild who just completed my rotations on the mobs I deemed important and/or saw that I was near the bottom of the rotation lists(10 guild rotation is one mob every 30 spawns, most mobs spawn maximum 6-8 times per month, so on a good day its a specific mob every 3-4 months), I would just wait for a choice repop when Class C mobs included something I wanted outside of VP and just go kill it. Then for the next 30 days I would go after FFA mobs during normal respawns (ie Taken) or if my guild never did FFA mobs (ie BDA) I would just relax and get reinstated to Class R in 30 days.

If I was in Class R and saw a guild wanted to rejoin Class R, at a minimum I would make the guild being reinstated wait an additional 30 days upon acceptance back to Class R before I put them back at the bottom of every rotation list. But that is a Class R concern, as Class R is their own entity and the rotation rules they use are decided by the Class R guilds in a private setting. I do not see any further point in discussing what Class R may or may not to do to guilds who request to rejoin Class R rotations. (A big guild could easily decide to hold the rotation hostage with a demand to get back in the rotation with choice spots or just compete on Class R mobs at their leisure only abiding by the server lock out rule.)

I would propose:
If a guild enters Class C, I would make them stay in Class C for 60 days minimum. If after 60 days the guild deems Class C is not for them they may elect to go back to Class R after a 30 day cool off period. During the cool off period the guild may only compete on FFA mobs.

Thus the exposure for the guild to be locked out of Class R is a minimum of 90 days.