Sky: Both Bard quest NPC spawn mobs give the same quests

[Arkis]

Upon attempting to finish the quest "Bard Test of the Wind" for the Fae Amulet, both Denise Songweaver and Clarisa Spiritsong give the same set of tests (pitch, voice, or tone). Therefore, neither are giving the test of wind, brass, or harmony.

According to this:

http://www.poopflingingmonkeys.com/eq/osw/skyquests.html

Clarisa should have the test of wind.

According to Allakhazam (most updated) http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=23 Denise should have the test of wind.

I do not know which is correct.

----------

http://img801.imageshack.us/i/bardquestnpcbugsky.png/

Also, both NPCs seem to be calling me "Gendal".

http://www.urbandictionary.com/products.php?term=Gendal&defid=4058356

Mean.

-----------
Adding, because I think this is a related issue in that one NPC might be giving the newer version quests and one is giving the older version quests...(even though theres two bugs squashed into one here, let me know if you want me to write this as a separate bug)

Another bard in my guild got "Songweaver's Mantle"

http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?item=4835

as a reward for completing the test of voice.

However, I got the "Mantle of the Songweaver".

http://img189.imageshack.us/i/mantleslol.png/

According to the comments it may have unlimited charges with the stats of "Songweaver's Mantle" but eventually was changed to "Mantle of the Songweaver" with 5 charges. The pic on allakhazam does not show charges for the older edition of it (however, this may just be because the older client might have not shown charges in general). This seems to be a mask of deception/guise of deceiver style nerf that happened later if this is the case. As of now, it should be "Songwaver's Mantle". Although, some of the comments suggest that it was charged without a counter. I don't know which is supposed to be correct to be honest. Was it just buffed? Or was it nerfed from being unlimited charges but buffed in stats to make up for it?

I turned in the quest via Denise, meanwhile he turned it in using Clarisa.

[Spirell]

already fixed :D I fixed that 2 days ago, but need to wait for the change for it to take effect

[Gwence]

so what is the fix going to be and are you going to retro it for me?

If songweaver's mantle is gonna have unlimited charges, I'd like to keep that obviously =p. If not I'll take the one Tones has!

[Spirell]

heheh I have no control over any of that :D I can only do things to test and submit corrections... you will have to ask nilbog/rogean about when it will go live, and a GM about getting items back

[Mystro]

Upon attempting to finish the quest "Bard Test of the Wind" for the Fae Amulet, both Denise Songweaver and Clarisa Spiritsong give the same set of tests (pitch, voice, or tone). Therefore, neither are giving the test of wind, brass, or harmony.

According to this:

http://www.poopflingingmonkeys.com/eq/osw/skyquests.html

Clarisa should have the test of wind.

According to Allakhazam (most updated) http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=23 Denise should have the test of wind.


----------

http://img801.imageshack.us/i/bardquestnpcbugsky.png/

Also, both NPCs seem to be calling me "Gendal".

http://www.urbandictionary.com/products.php?term=Gendal&defid=4058356

Mean.

-----------
Adding, because I think this is a related issue in that one NPC might be giving the newer version quests and one is giving the older version quests...(even though theres two bugs squashed into one here, let me know if you want me to write this as a separate bug)

Another bard in my guild got "Songweaver's Mantle"

http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?item=4835

as a reward for completing the test of voice.

However, I got the "Mantle of the Songweaver".

http://img189.imageshack.us/i/mantleslol.png/

According to the comments it may have unlimited charges with the stats of "Songweaver's Mantle" but eventually was changed to "Mantle of the Songweaver" with 5 charges. The pic on allakhazam does not show charges for the older edition of it (however, this may just be because the older client might have not shown charges in general). This seems to be a mask of deception/guise of deceiver style nerf that happened later if this is the case. As of now, it should be "Songwaver's Mantle". Although, some of the comments suggest that it was charged without a counter. I don't know which is supposed to be correct to be honest. Was it just buffed? Or was it nerfed from being unlimited charges but buffed in stats to make up for it?

I turned in the quest via Denise, meanwhile he turned it in using Clarisa.


I'm bringing back this thread because I recently handed in items for the "mantle of the songweaver" (bards test of voice) to clarisa which is suppose to start with her (as shown in these links): http://everquest.allakhazam.com/db/quest.html?quest=597 and http://wiki.project1999.org/index.php/Bard_Plane_of_Sky_Tests.. I think there is few discrepancies between who to hand these into.

Mind you, I didn't bother talk to her upon me handing in my items (which she ate) because I figured I had a reliable source.

As I patiently await for my reimbursement I think it would be a good idea for someone to check this out... Again.
I do not know which is correct.