Reaver is not a magic item
 

Reaver, the sword dropped by Statue, is not Magic.

That's why it sucks. But it looks like it is magic here.

Click goblin skull earring, non magic weapon is now magic, its like magic

Fixed, pending update

wow, why does that weapon suck so bad considering other items on loot table are goog

It's a good weapon when it works.

it should be 35/45 here non magic

was later upgraded to 36/40 non magic (during velious)
was later upgraded to 40/40 non magic (during velious)
then later again MAGIC was added (after velious 2003)